Well not to sound creepy but the hymen does repair itself, but it more flexible each time. Maybe you need deeper fucking before going for the full four fingers
Nails need to be trimmed and not be too rough
Does he have long nails?
If not you might have vaginal problems and need to see a doctor.
It's possible he could've cut/scratched the inside. You can't always feel that. Be careful!
This is likely the scenario. Sometimes you don't feel it, but tears or scratches can occur anyways. Especially in dry weather like now.
maybe you were on ur period? or he scratched you with his nail
Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions
What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!Yo wtf
Due the nail
Maybe you started having periods
Im not a doctor so maybe its your period
U should go to the doctor
You probably just have a really tight pussy
Tore you inside.
guy "friend", fingered you? lmao
Yeah it's complicated were more friends with benefits
friends with benefits is a relationship, without a label
Too rough or sharp fingernails
I like do finger girls pussy
Sexual Relationships 
Sexual Health 
Most Helpful Guys