I guess it's all relative. I would have said small based on just reading the question, but then going by the two links, I slightly prefer the bigger of the two (pic #1). But let me look at both again just to be sure. :-)
Picture 2 has no ass.
none of the above. I like my round in shape butt that's on the larger side. That skinny butt is nasty though. Looks like it should belong to a 50 year old
Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions
What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!both are pretty unattractive to me. But idk.. skinny is always better for me. I'm a smaller guy myself.
not a fan of either of those, but I tend to like a bigger one of those two options.
rounded tone butt is better than both though
Wow that's a skinny ass! :O I don't even think that's natural, I prefer the bigger butt
Neither of them have cottage-cheese-ass going on, so they're both fine as far as I'm concerned.
lol, they both look flat to me.
Sexual Relationships 
Sexual Health 
Most Helpful Guys