What's hottest-a thin girl, fit girl, or muscular girl?

[xobrowneyedbeauty]

Just wondering which one guys find most attractive and which one girls would most prefer to be.

[kholland65]

I'm not exactly sure the difference between these 3 but I'll assume by these you mean:

Skinny - as in skin and bones, barely any fat content, looks borderline anorexic.

Fit - No overweight or underweight. The ideal weight. No extra muscle tone.

Muscular - has visible muscle definition.

If this is correct I would go for fit. I would take skinny over fat, but I still don't like a girl who is skin and bones, I also am not a huge fan of girls that look like they could almost kick my ass. I like smooth curves, not muscular and bumpy ones. It's just to masculine looking. Still though, I would personally take all 3 of these over fat any day. I just can't get into overweight girls.

[kholland65]

Update: my answer stands. Def fit is my fav

[Orion]

Fit pretty much wins since it's right down the middle. Some guys do like thin girls but fit means you can wear just about anything and look good. Muscular girls tend to lose a little femininity. That's not to say there aren't guys that don't appreciate thin and muscular, it's just fit is the optimal choice.

[Kearra]

What about curvier girls.

link

[StewieG]

I like someone "toned" so if that's what you mean by fit.

I don't like super skinny with no muscle tone.

I also don't like a girl that is super muscular.

[Giwreh]

Without hesitation : muscular. (More then the example from the link)

[foolycooly1001]

What's the difference between a and b?

[NotJustAnotherGuy]

One just doesn't eat like a f***ing boar. The other is actually athletic.

[foolycooly1001]

I meant in appearance.

[NotJustAnotherGuy]

muscularity. I can't see how B and C are different though.. Unless by C she is referring to steroid use bodybuilder females.

[jvonder]

Personally I prefer a little cushion on girls, just a little jiggle in her wiggle.

Example:

link

[burn27]

Holy shlt yes!

[StewieG]

Yea, I like that.

[Malcom_Reynolds]

Those are pretty extreme examples, the only one of those who looked like she could be a normal girl was the fit one.

I've always admitted to liking skinny girls (admittedly I like athletic girls more) but if you're skinny to the point of seeing bones, then it's too far. And I don't like visible abs on girls. I'm all for having a toned stomach, but keep it flat and smooth, not ripped.

[LilKim]

Those skinny girls are sickening.

[Xx_DRE_xX]

It's generally be B, but I would definitely take C.

[NotJustAnotherGuy]

What is considered the difference between B and C ?

[Xx_DRE_xX]

One actually lifts and has some actual muscle definition.

[NotJustAnotherGuy]

Really, because I would think a fit girl would do that o.O .. fit is adjective that derives from the noun fitness..

[Alpha93]

Fit or muscular

[lee-cooper]

which one is beyonce ?

[RikkiTikkiTavi]

a fit birdie ;)

[Lj236]

id say the fit one

[Lj236]

definitely the fit one

[Anonymous]

Fit would be closest to my personal preference...I like a toned smooth tummy, maybe just a very slight swell.

[Anonymous]

fit girl .

[Anonymous]

I don't want a girl who's weak but I don't want a girl with guy-sized muscles either so fit.

[Opinion Owner]

with the pictures, both fit and muscular are good

[Anonymous]

A thin, fit girl with a bit of muscle. That probably doesn`t help.

Muscular is okay but only to a point, then it starts to get ugly, and a bit masculin looking. Thin and boney is just not good. Fit but a bit chubby isn`t great either, but better than boney.

If I had to pick one of the three though, it would be fit all the way.