A castrated man is still a man. Do you agree or disagree?

[Anonymous]

A castrated man is still a man or a mutilated penis isn’t a vagina.

Do you agree or disagree?

[artgorgeous]

Yes, he is still a man. Just without balls.

[Asker]

I saw this question a little while back. Many users were still calling these trans women “men” even after they have had the surgery.

Guys, would you imagine and consider dating a transgender woman even if she's done the sex reassignment surgery? ↗

[artgorgeous]

But they are still men. Just have modified genitals.

[MaxUsefull]

castrated on the balls or on the cock?

[Asker]

Both

[MaxUsefull]

I'm scared to ask why you asked that

[Asker]

I’m NOT thinking of attack other men don’t worry

[MaxUsefull]

technically what defines a man is the xy chromosome, so, yes, he is a man, but for obvious reasons he will never be able to marry

[Asker]

Transgender women who were born in male bodies get surgery on their genitalia to look more like women and it helps them feel more like a woman I have seen more than one user on this website in the past write things like “a mutilated man is still a man.”

[MaxUsefull]

Transgender woman is just a man pretending to be a woman

[Asker]

I saw this question a little while ago
Guys, would you imagine and consider dating a transgender woman even if she's done the sex reassignment surgery? ↗

sex reassignment surgery means these transgender women who were born with penises basically got them surgically removed.
Many people in the comment section were still calling them men even after the surgery

[MaxUsefull]

Yes, in my point of view still a man

[Asker]

I’m not thinking of hurting anyone. I’m not a sociopath I just thought of this question because I remember seeing that other question a little while back. Those trans women have basically got their penises surgically removed but many other users were still calling them “men”

[MaxUsefull]

the truth is sometimes not pleasant

[Asker]

It’s likely these trans women don’t even have vaginal internal organs after the surgery to such as uterus, fallopian tubes, cervix and ovaries

[Boromir]

Being a man is linked to your DNA. XY is male and XX is female. Without a penis and testicles you’re still a man, just a damaged man. Gender is binary, and is assigned at conception.

[BadApple69]

Totally agree.

[Guffrus]

That is an interesting question.

Well, the answer is certainly interesting, I'm not sure the question is actually but one leads to the other so maybe that counts? Though I disappointedly suspect that you are just another ignorant shit for brained cunt who is jumping on the lets hate trans band wagon because you aren't interesting enough to have your own thoughts.

This taken from one of Girlwriteswhat?'s videos which says that a man's value to society is his work, men are sacrificed most obviously in wars but also through dangerous work etc so a man can still contribute to society but a woman with no womb is nothing at all.

Now, these are obviously very old and sort of base ideas which are not directly applicable to the modern world but there is still an undercurrent of truth to them and it is easy to see how these ideas would or could come back forcefully in a survival of the species scenario.

[worldscolide]

You cannot change genetics, if you were born with x and y chromosomes, you're male end of story, end of discussion. If you're born with two x chromosomes you're female, end of story, end of discussion.

[smilelots]

Castrated man can’t produce offspring I don’t know anybody that’s been castrated so I don’t know if it changes the way they think in the way they feel and sexually what it does to them but I believe if you have a penis and you think you’re a man, then you’re a man

[Brady]

agree

[BeetleBro2000]

I agree. Some people get very hung up on genitals, it's nice some people still understand being a man isn't about what's in your pants or if you got "well endowed" enough.

[shades777]

born a man die a man

[OddBeMe]

Apparently it depends on personal ideas of masculinity. And im ok with that. Perhaps just leave each other alone on genital shit. Whaddya think?

[Charliefretz329]

I completely agree!

[Charliefretz329]

But a man who only removes penis is more manly than one who removes only balls cause testosterone comes from balls. And of course least manly is the one who removes both penis and balls. But any way the man is still a man. Especially if he takes supplements and works out to maintain his figure.

[Milkingballs25]

Balls are the main part of men body. So if balls are not there then men are not men.

Balls playing and squeezing is very hot

[Travellover]

Yes of course

[Benplus10]

A man is a state of mind. Being manly, etc. a castrated man is called a eunuch. Could be a man due to (his) state of mind, but not a male I don’t think. difficult one due to everyone using different gender labels these days

[Asker]

The definition of man means adult human male

[Anonymous]

Agree. The ability to father children doesn’t define someone.

[Anonymous]

I don't think that a castrated man is still a man, only look like a man.
But also I don't think transgender women are real women, removing your genitals doesn't change your sex, it's just a mutilation and deformation in my opinion.

[Anonymous]

Yes I agree but also cause a women who had her tubes tied is still a woman.

But more your saying a guy who has his dick turned into a pussy is still a MAN. Very much agree.

Which is why trans apart from the internet and small circles are not very well liked and they don't look like women without all the make up right angles and voice changer.

They sound like dumb gay men and look like drag queens. Normal guys won't date them cause they feel it's gay.

Only in porn do guys think it looks hot.

Most trans want to go back after surgery and have a high suicide rate! We need to address it as it should be... an issue in mental health