They wouldn't be called transwomen then, would they?
It's like asking if a fake Gucci bag well made can be called a "genuine" if it's a good enough copy.
1000
DermalPunchExplorer
1 y
No, they are not. Period.
0401
JessicaEarlXper 6
1 y
I believe that everyone should be loved and respected and have equal rights under the constitutional law. If someone wants to go by a pronoun, we should use it the same way we call them a name they prefer and don’t call them names they don’t like. However when this effects people outside of this person, I believe we should find other alternatives to full and complete treatment as this gender outside of their sex. I don’t believe gendered bathrooms should go away. I don’t believe biological males should compete against biological females in sports. I don’t believe medicine should treat them as another sex. Essentially, when it comes to social situations, I believe they should be treated as their gender simply to invite unity to our country that desperately needs it. But when it comes to physical judgements, it should be by their sex.
0002
Th3ftExplorer
1 y
Lol! Well this was a bomb show of a question…haha! i would NEVER suggest that a trans girl was not a girl but I will say that there is no way for them to ever be woman. You can’t start off with testosterone and then remove the effects. Those years will always be with you! i will always be friendly toward and try to treat them with the same respect and dignity I would treat any woman but a trans girl is and will always be a trans girl. In my mind at least.
0000
SpotifyplaylistXper 5
1 y
Of course!
0103
DargilMaster
1 y
Give them a DNA test. XY, men. XX, women.
0000
FunkyMonkeeMaster
1 y
Yes.
0001
andreasderjuengereMaster
1 y
There are no ''trans-women'' in my own world. Only disturbed personalities with a range of body modifications. I'm out.
0001
jengeorge26
1 y
Yes, we can call them sissy Boi
anon1903Guru
1 y
Yes! Let's treat them like one.
0110
_deeznutsXper 6
1 y
most of y'all transphobic as fuck, ofc they are women
3003
lofii
1 y
No they aren't
_deeznuts
1 y
@lofii why not then
Lycanthropic
1 y
Because then they would be women, not trans-women.
Show All Show Less
user73463767
1 y
@Lycanthropic Trans is an adjective. Guess blonde women aren't women, because then they'd just be women Guess short women aren't women, because then they'd just be women Guess cis women aren't women, because then they'd just be women- the list goes on and on- the use of an adjective doesn't make a women less of a women
lofii
1 y
Trannys aren't women. The fact that you ask "why not" is just plain stupidity. Just cause IT looks like a woman doesn't make it one. People who think like you are a cancer to society
_deeznuts
1 y
@lofii whoa there calm down i know a couple of transwomen, and to put it in your terms they are quite literally women. There is nothing about them that screams man. I have a trans cousin that transferred when she was like seven, everything about her is a women. I didn't even know until two years ago. Being born in the wrong body has nothing to do with how they think emotionally. There is no difference between a trans-women and a women beside how they became one.
lofii
1 y
Thinking you're born in the wrong body are signs of mental illness. Unacceptance of reality. Which leads to poor choices like mutilating your own body.
lofii
1 y
Being scientifically modified doesn't make you a woman. Being born as such makes you a woman. That's why men have Adam's apple and women don't. Men have a more broad shoulder shape than women. You can't change those features meaning you were born a man. You are a man. You're a mentally ill man that wants to live In Lala land thinking he's a real woman. The only thing worse than that are the people humouring this nonsense using their emotional logic to pander to that person's mental illness
_deeznuts
1 y
@lofii okay dumbo whatever u want
lofii
1 y
Whatever I want? Let me smash then
Phoenix98Master
1 y
I believe that they think they are.
But biologically they aren’t, their chromosomes which dictate what you are can’t be changed or altered. There for they are still men.
Whatever they think or feel on the matter the facts, science and biology say otherwise.
0000
FilmGuy93Guru
1 y
If it has a penis; it's not a woman.
0000
IveGotNoNameYoda
1 y
Sorry but no, I don't believe so. I would never criticize anyone doing anything with their life that doesn't affect others, but I don't have to believe it.
0300
Danny_dan92Master
1 y
Nope. A woman can give birth and has menstral cycles
0000
TheSpaceGnomeGuru
1 y
Nope. Just like I don't think the actor who played davey jones is an octopus man. You can make yourself look like lots of things you aren't, sometimes you might fool people for a bit if it's convincing enough, but it's not the same as actually being it.
0100
VikingWarLordYoda
1 y
I'd never date or have sex with one.
The fact that they were once a dude, is a turn off to me
0000
genericname85Master
1 y
of course not. they are "trans women", not "women" or else we'd call them just "women".
0000
genericname85
1 y
it is not possible to ever "become" the other gender. you can get good at pretending to be the other egnder. you can even get surgery to physically look a lot like it and you can convince everyon around you to treat you like the other gender. but you'll still never "be" the other gender.
Literalbillionaire17Xper 6
1 y
I don't know tbh. I would say yes because I think people should be whoever they want to be. I also think though it’s a lot being a woman that trans woman won’t understand. I don't know
0000
jengeorge26Xper 6
1 y
If they had surgery and on female hormones, they sure are not men anymore, so I suppose they are now female
0011
JessicaEarl
1 y
They may not be men, but they can’t change their chromosomes. So they will never be female
What Girls & Guys Said
33 75No judgment but no…. Will leave it at that.
They wouldn't be called transwomen then, would they?
It's like asking if a fake Gucci bag well made can be called a "genuine" if it's a good enough copy.
No, they are not. Period.
I believe that everyone should be loved and respected and have equal rights under the constitutional law. If someone wants to go by a pronoun, we should use it the same way we call them a name they prefer and don’t call them names they don’t like. However when this effects people outside of this person, I believe we should find other alternatives to full and complete treatment as this gender outside of their sex. I don’t believe gendered bathrooms should go away. I don’t believe biological males should compete against biological females in sports. I don’t believe medicine should treat them as another sex. Essentially, when it comes to social situations, I believe they should be treated as their gender simply to invite unity to our country that desperately needs it. But when it comes to physical judgements, it should be by their sex.
Lol! Well this was a bomb show of a question…haha!
i would NEVER suggest that a trans girl was not a girl but I will say that there is no way for them to ever be woman. You can’t start off with testosterone and then remove the effects. Those years will always be with you!
i will always be friendly toward and try to treat them with the same respect and dignity I would treat any woman but a trans girl is and will always be a trans girl. In my mind at least.
Of course!
Give them a DNA test. XY, men. XX, women.
Yes.
There are no ''trans-women'' in my own world.
Only disturbed personalities with a range of body modifications.
I'm out.
Yes, we can call them sissy Boi
Yes! Let's treat them like one.
most of y'all transphobic as fuck, ofc they are women
No they aren't
@lofii why not then
Because then they would be women, not trans-women.
@Lycanthropic Trans is an adjective. Guess blonde women aren't women, because then they'd just be women Guess short women aren't women, because then they'd just be women Guess cis women aren't women, because then they'd just be women- the list goes on and on- the use of an adjective doesn't make a women less of a women
Trannys aren't women. The fact that you ask "why not" is just plain stupidity. Just cause IT looks like a woman doesn't make it one. People who think like you are a cancer to society
@lofii whoa there calm down i know a couple of transwomen, and to put it in your terms they are quite literally women. There is nothing about them that screams man. I have a trans cousin that transferred when she was like seven, everything about her is a women. I didn't even know until two years ago. Being born in the wrong body has nothing to do with how they think emotionally. There is no difference between a trans-women and a women beside how they became one.
Thinking you're born in the wrong body are signs of mental illness. Unacceptance of reality. Which leads to poor choices like mutilating your own body.
Being scientifically modified doesn't make you a woman. Being born as such makes you a woman. That's why men have Adam's apple and women don't. Men have a more broad shoulder shape than women. You can't change those features meaning you were born a man. You are a man. You're a mentally ill man that wants to live In Lala land thinking he's a real woman. The only thing worse than that are the people humouring this nonsense using their emotional logic to pander to that person's mental illness
@lofii okay dumbo whatever u want
Whatever I want? Let me smash then
I believe that they think they are.
But biologically they aren’t, their chromosomes which dictate what you are can’t be changed or altered. There for they are still men.
Whatever they think or feel on the matter the facts, science and biology say otherwise.
If it has a penis; it's not a woman.
Sorry but no, I don't believe so. I would never criticize anyone doing anything with their life that doesn't affect others, but I don't have to believe it.
Nope. A woman can give birth and has menstral cycles
Nope. Just like I don't think the actor who played davey jones is an octopus man.
You can make yourself look like lots of things you aren't, sometimes you might fool people for a bit if it's convincing enough, but it's not the same as actually being it.
I'd never date or have sex with one.
The fact that they were once a dude, is a turn off to me
of course not. they are "trans women", not "women" or else we'd call them just "women".
it is not possible to ever "become" the other gender. you can get good at pretending to be the other egnder. you can even get surgery to physically look a lot like it and you can convince everyon around you to treat you like the other gender. but you'll still never "be" the other gender.
I don't know tbh. I would say yes because I think people should be whoever they want to be. I also think though it’s a lot being a woman that trans woman won’t understand. I don't know
If they had surgery and on female hormones, they sure are not men anymore, so I suppose they are now female
They may not be men, but they can’t change their chromosomes. So they will never be female
True, not a real female, but not a man anymore
Just a little sissy