Girls, which guy would you choose?

[stratford]

Many guys in life are obsessed about the size of their penis so I thought I would pose a question to the girls on here to explore this from a different perspective to add a twist.

So, imagine this scenario:

There are two guys, they are identical in every way, except for their penis. They are your perfect 10 in all aspects - looks, character, emotion and also in the bedroom they both match in terms of sexual preference, hardness, staying power, etc.

The only different is that their penis length and girth is different. Which would you choose?

I have intentionally left out the option for 'I don't mind' as in this scenario you can only choose one guy.

Would be great to hear your reason for your choice too, and also any guys perspective on this.

[DizzyDesii]

8.5 is too much. 4.5 is not enough. I’ll take my chances the longer guy because at least i can take as much as i want though not all. I literally was with both before except one was over 8.3 at the start of our relationship and past that at the end. The other, I don't know if he was even 4.5 but it just wasn't enough. He only came in handy during oral. The ideal size would be 5-7 inches

[stratford]

Thanks for the detailed reply. The guy who was 8.3", did you mean that his penis was still growing and he ended up longer than that? The guy who was 4.5" was he too small for you to feel anything uring PIV but his oral skills made up for it?

[DizzyDesii]

Yea he was 7 something soft and 8.3 hard. By the end of our relationship 2 years later, it was even longer. I dont think i ever took him balls deep but i def remember feeling it in my stomach. And for the smaller guy, i could feel if we were doing certain positions but other than that, he was better in terms of me giving him oral because i didn't gag


Those allowed him to go deep which was fine cause they’re two of my fave positions anyways. But he wasn't long enough nor strong enough to do my third fave position

[stratford]

Wow - totally love this response! Did you enjoy the feeling of being full with the bigger guy?

[DizzyDesii]

Yes but the pain after the sex hurt so bad because he legit felt like he was in my stomach. But the pain was usually worth it 😂 Honestly even the smaller dude hit deep in the two positions infirst listed so both made me hurt after. Or maybe i just hurt more wih the other guy because we went all day

[stratford]

Sounds like they both hit the spot! Did you have a problem gagging while deep throating the larger guy? Did he ever have issues staying hard?

[DizzyDesii]

I refused to suck him. I bit the shit out the tip of his dick for trying to force himself on me

[stratford]

Ouch!

[Anonymous]

8.5 is still smaller than I prefer... I like my men to bottom out which usually takes about 9 for me.

[stratford]

Do you like girth as well as length? Does it get painful when they bottom out?

[Opinion Owner]

Yes, and yes... But I love the hurt... It makes me feel more submissive and used.

[stratford]

Would love to chat more about this if you could PM me :-)

[neilsmart]

8.5 inches wins every time

[stratford]

What is the biggest you have taken in your mouth and kitty?

[tralalala38]

Non cause this will never happen

[stratford]

It's a hypothetical question so you are correct, but also you have to choose only one, you can't say none 😂

[tralalala38]

Well I just did lol

[Anonymous]

Oh brother, not another penis question. 🤣