Well, fingers are more solid than a penis. Penises can be squeezed. So it's possible that your pussy squeezed them down to the right size. :P
Next time you are very turned on and wet try slipping a second finger inside yourself and you may find that it will just slide in. Voila
you're P is just tight. its not a bad thing at all! as long as its pleasurable, i wouldn't worry about it too much :)
Uh... maybe you're just not relaxed enough? Because I'm a virgin and I can fit two.
you are too tense... i suggest getting a toy instead :) x
C'mon, she ain't desperate.
@RexCatholicissimus toys doesn't make a girl desperate, it makes playing more fun
Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions
What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!You have to be horny to feel the difference, i suppose.
Normal, that's why its like knocking on a door when you try dry sex haha. Shits closed before wet
the pussy can stretch, so that would be why your partners can go in
Should be able fit more than one! Are you wet?
I know and yes very very wet
Nothing to worry about, when X2 message u. serious, driving me mad, love know why, only one finger. Be cool, hope having fun, day
maybe your muscles contract when you try to do it yourself.
I'll stretch you out real good
Sexual Relationships 
Sexual Health 
Most Helpful Guys