Guys, I'm biologically female who only likes men, but I can only get aroused when I imagine having sex as a male. What do guys think about this?

It just never works when I picture myself having sex as a female. I don't get turned on; the opposite happens. It totally grosses me out. No one taught me to be this way; it just is. If you don't believe me or are averse to the idea, no need to insult me. I'm looking for honest and constructive opinions or feedback that will help me. Needless to say, I've been very confused about this… "tendency" myself. A therapist only even recently pointed out that I do this (as I wasn't even aware of doing it, and always chalked it up to me being asexual, but it turns out that isn't the case at all) and suggested that perhaps I am transmasculine, and while I do relate much better to males than females for most things, I have no desire to transition physically (surgery or meds, etc. is an absolute no-no). (I'm kinda okay, uhm… "accepting"? of my biological gender, but deep down, I realised that I've always kind of envied boys and often just feel more at home around them.) I know this "projecting as a male" to feel sexually liberated (or at least, that's what I call it for now) can be attributed to a hundred things (but it's not like I got the idea from anyone else, it just happened naturally since I was very young‚ and I am old - generation x), but I was just wondering what boys think about girls who have this… err, frame of mind? I haven't really come out to anyone about this since it's very personal. I'm the type of person who doesn't like attention and would rather be invisible, as much as possible. Thank you in advance for any help, honest opinion, and for being respectful all around.

0 0

AI Bot Choice

Superb Opinion
  • Unfortunately, it's not uncommon for therapists to plant seeds we never previously even considered. Gender issues can be complicated. Most people don't have a clear understanding of what it feels like to be the gender they are and don't even concern themselves with what it feels like to be that gender. Since we don't generally identify what it means to be the gender we are, it can be hard for people to understand when others insist they know what it feels like to be the opposite gender.

    You say this has nothing to do with traits that are commonly associated with males (ie aggression, power and control), but you just picture yourself with male genitalia. Sometimes this can grow from early experiences of negative comments about female genitalia. I've heard women say they were taught from an early age that they were dirty, ugly and smelly, but, when they get married, it will be a beautiful gift to give to their husband. On their wedding night they looked at themselves and realized they didn't change. They confronted their parents who said "We did what we had to do... you didn't get pregnant... if you have a hangup, that's your problem to fix." People are often very inconsiderate of others, only thinking about what's in their best interest. You may have received subtle (or not so subtle) messages from an early age (that you may not even remember), implying male genitalia were more attractive or valued than female genitalia. It's hard to overcome early indoctrination, even when that indoctrination makes no sense.

    Another related issue is male figures often pull away from girls when they start to develop, fearful others will negatively judge them for wrestling or hugging girls who now have breasts. Not wanting to be inappropriate, they stop the interactions the girls have enjoyed all their life. Girls then feel they are being punished for having breasts and often do their best to conceal their breasts and do more "boy" behaviors, hoping they can reconnect with their loved male figures.

    Your body parts are just as attractive and valued as male body parts. You just have never taken the time to explore and discover their beauty and value. What do you believe you can do or experience with male body parts that is more significant than what you can do with female body parts? You may just be jealous that male parts can be seen and actively manipulated, whereas female body parts can be seen as primarily hidden and unknown, or don't like having to deal with periods every month. Relabel your clit as a beautiful and fully functional body part rather than just a tiny insignificant penis. It's not what we have but how we use what we have that leads to meaningful encounters. Learning to make the most of what you have is more likely to lead to satisfaction than fantasizing about being different.

    You say you don't like attention, and that is common for an introvert, but you do like men. Do you get attention you appreciate from your partner, or do you just view your encounters as vicariously living through him? Hopefully, you have a caring, sensitive partner who shows you how much he appreciates you, just like you may be showing him how much you appreciate him. Healthy relationships are more about the connection than the performance. Find what really works for you, and then enjoy your experiences.

    • Hey, thanks for that. Yes, all your points are perfectly valid and I agree. See, the thing is this (and this might surprise you): I am actually a very well-treated female. People around me shower me constantly with praise (more than I feel I deserve sometimes, but hey, it's their opinions and I'm not one to want to control or change that; I respect and appreciate honesty above all). OK, full disclosure, I don't think I am all that pretty and sexy, but I actually get called pretty, sexy, hot, intelligent, etc. A LOT. So much so that it makes me want to hide because I am not very good with compliments (as I've said, I don't like attention all that much, positive or negative, haha). I'm a geek, and yes, a total introvert, and I prefer to keep to myself. However, my job—or jobs—require that I mingle a lot and meet a lot of people and work with them. I've got many advances and offers from both male and female (more of males) all throughout my life—more than I know what to do with (both from single and committed people, ugh). I turned them all down nicely. I've had a boyfriend or two, and it was a wonderful experience, but this is where it all becomes problematic. As I explained in one of my replies above: I FEEL GUILTY BEING IN A ROMANTIC RELATIONSHIP AS A GIRL. And no, it's not because I feel ugly as a girl, in fact, I like how I look as a girl—not saying I'm the prettiest, I just like how I look because it fits who I am (and I am no supermodel nor celebrity, I'm just a geeky, somewhat athletic and boyish girl).

    • (PART 2) What about being a male makes me feel freer? HELL, EVERYTHING! I don't like breasts. I HATE HAVING BREASTS TOUCHED SEXUALLY. I even hate having to soap and scrub my own breasts when I bathe. It's not a conscious choice to feel this way, it's visceral. I don't even remember I feel this until I touch myself to wash, and I get this jolting feeling of revulsion. Not saying the male body is perfect; not saying the female body is any less (though I really do not like female bits). Thing is, I wouldn't mind keeping my female body during the sexual act, IF ONLY MY PARTNER WOULD TREAT ME LIKE IT WAS A MALE BODY. Okay, I know that sounds ridiculous. I don't know how else to put it, maybe I am phrasing it wrong or something, but like I said, my sexual experiences with my boyfriends only went as far as kissing, hugging, holding hands and as much as I was really attracted to them, when I remember I am a female and being touched as one, I feel nauseous and I want to run FAR FAR FAR AWAY. Again, visceral reaction; not a conscious decision.

    • (PART 3) Like I mentioned, I've always thought this was due to me being asexual. But weirdly, I am a very sexual person. I just cannot for the life of me be present as a female in the sexual act. I realised the only way I feel free to enjoy sex is if I imagine I am a boy. I still touch myself, and NSFW: I ENJOY TOUCHING MYSELF A LOT, but only when I forget it's my clit I am touching and imagine it's a penis, and forget it's nipples of my breasts I'm tweaking but imagine it's a male chest. I don't mind being penetrated (though I never have been by any partner because as I mentioned I am a virgin), but I do use toys, and even when I fuck myself, I picture it's a male's ass. THERE. I said it. This is the first time I have went and confessed all the sordid details of this. I feel really tiny and embarrassed right now, but yeah. That's the truth. I wish I understood this better myself. Maybe you're right and this stems from some inner self loathing or something, but if it is, I don't know where it comes from and I have thought about this from all angles, so many times, that it makes my head hurt. I just posted this because I wanted to know what a guy would think if they met a girl they liked who happened to have this… I dunno, weird kink? Fetish? Tendency? Whatever this is. But I feel sad sometimes because I am sooooo sooooo very in love, but I don't know what to do with it. I don't know how to approach a guy a like because I feel like a freak. I want to be loved and to love someone so much, but I feel like if I have to be intimately romantically involved with someone as a female, that overpowering guilt will hang over my head, and I can't. I can't do it. And I have tried. Anyway, thank you for your insightful reply. I appreciate it and it definitely will be food for thought. Perhaps I need to do more introspection, or maybe I should just forget about love in real life altogether. Heh. :')

    • Show All

Most Helpful Guy

  • u got my attention cuz of the respected & cute way ur asking..
    in my opinion it may happen for multi reasons..
    it can be cuz u didn't masturbate when u become adult in ur teenage time.. maybe u didn't explore urself, how to plesure urself, how to get orgasms..
    it can happen cuz u consider urself as unattractive or u have low self confidence..
    or maybe someone around u tell that regularly to u..
    google and you tube is really full of free helpful information, its really another world to find everything ur looking for easily..
    so i advice u to forget about asexual thoughts & bisexual or lesbian etc... of fucking stuff..
    u focus on ur feminine futures, try to feel and be sub girl...
    use google and always be straight.
    make female friends and try to understand and explore them&urself..
    dont be cheap to anyone... save urself till u get married

    • thanks for the mho

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Guys Said

(10)
  • Make no sense, why you imagine that you a man when you have a woman's body? it's odd.

    • If it made sense, I wouldn't be confused about it and I wouldn't be wondering about it in the first place. That's the whole idea. Also, a lot of things in this world make no sense to a lot of people. Doesn't mean it is wrong or not valid just because people don't understand it.

    • At least it less messed up than being full on trans, but you need accept your body.

    • Yes, I have no desire to transition via surgery. I do appreciate my body to a certain degree, and I like who I am but I feel so uncomfortable as a female. When I imagine everything as a male, it becomes so much better, feels so much more natural and I am so much happier. Well, I never let being a female stand in the way of what I wanted anyway, I mean, I've always enjoyed doing boy things and hanging out with guys more. But… yes, it's the sex part that makes it complicated. I've fallen in love many times, and I've had a fair share of men like me, but that's where I get totally lost. I dunno how to tell them I want to be treated like a… well, a boy. :') Anyway, thanks for your input all the same, I appreciate it.

    • Show All
  • What Are Odd Symptoms of Mental Illness? For 200 Alez

    Sounds like a variant of Schizophrenia. You are not crazy, your mind (self), and brain (the organ) are out of synch with the rest of your body.

    • I checked and also been through therapists. Nope. I don't have any other disorders or mental illnesses in line with that (this is according to professionals). Except perhaps bodily dysmorphia? But that one isn't a formal diagnosis. It's just a self observation.

    • Did you see a psychiatrist /neurologists that are specialists with that particular disorder?

    • Yeah, heh. I have seen more than a dozen. They say when it comes to that aspect, I am perfectly normal. That there are many people in this world who feel the same way I do, they just aren't as "seen" as the rest of the "normal" people are. I actually have no problem with this if it were only up to me. The reason I ventured to make this post is I was curious what actual men thought if they happened to, for instance, fall in love with a girl who was like me when it came to intimacy. So… hehe. Yeah. Just testing the waters. My past relationships have been wonderful, though I had them when I was very young. But in those relationships, I acted like the perfect prim and proper "girl" that I was expected to me. Still boyish and all, because I can never be girly, but we never got farther than kissing, and even that in itself made me queasy. I loved kissing, but something always felt wrong somehow… :(

    • Show All
  • Find a guy who enjoys pegging and being stroked.

    • Hi, thanks for the reply. Oh. That's actually the catch. I don't have any fantasies of dominating men or "pegging". Well, none yet, so far, haha. I don't mind having being the submissive in the relationship, but I just don't get turned on being treated as a female. Sorry if that sounds confusing. I am trying to word it without sounding offensive. Uhm, how do I say this: I just don't like being reminded that I have… err, lady bits. BIT NSFW: To be blunt, when I touch myself, I picture a penis and chest. Not female parts. If I am reminded of my female parts, I get repulsed. :( I hope that makes sense somehow.

    • So if your not into pegging, that's means during sex you only prefer anal on you?

    • @FrostDragone88 Not necessarily. Maybe if I were actually born a guy, I could confidently answer with a "yes"? I wouldn't know. But the thing is, since I am biologically female, I have never had actual sex with ANYONE. Because I am so repulsed by the idea of exposing my female body to the sexual act. Yes, I am a virgin.

    • Show All
  • You're overthinking this.

    It's completely normal for a straight person to only be turned on by looking at the opposite gender, and to find their own gender's junk repulsive.

    Its why I (or any other straight male) watches lesbian porn.

    You're not supposed to focus on your own body when having sex, you're supposed to ignore it.

    • I totally get what you mean. But it's a bit more complex than that. I regret that I don't have the expertise to explain it, but, I will try to expound on why it's more a bit more complex than that. I fall in love with men ONLY: check. Not attracted at all to females, or female bodies (in fact, female bodies kinda make me wanna run away): check. Now, when I had boyfriends before, I liked them a lot but it always made me uncomfortable to a certain degree and I never understood why (but hey, I was like 14 and 15, so… there were a whole lotta things I did not understand). They were great boyfriends. But I broke up with them because of this… GUILT I could not explain. I realised only MUCH MUCH LATER, it's because I hate being treated like a girl. Sorry, weird. I know. Don't know how else to put it. I just came to this conclusion because I realised that when I project myself into a male body - a guy, and have the same relationship with a boy I like, EVERYTHING IS MAGICALLY OKAY. Fantastic even. Much like how guys like lesbian porn, I TOTALLY LOVE GAY PORN (but gay porn where guys still act like guys, not where guys act girly – though I have nothing against those, anything overtly girly just turns me the hell off). I even hate my own breasts being touched like breasts. I hate how they jiggle and bounce (I'm a 36B so, ugh). I LITERALLY WANNA HAVE A FLAT CHEST, not small tits, like I fantasise about having a male chest. But not enough to want to undergo surgery for it. I feel sad because I want to love someone and be loved romantically but as long as I am a girl and treated like one, I feel wrong about it. I apologise if this is confusing. I am confused about it myself. But that's honestly how it feels after I did much thinking and introspection about it.

    • You're still overthinking it and focusing too much on your own body.. If you want to be with a guy, he's going to want you to have boobs, vagina, and overall look like a woman, you just have to get over the fact that sexual situations are not just about pleasuring you, but also the person you are with, you are trying to view being selfish as being "trans", which is absurd. You only wajt a flat chest because you want to be turned on by yourself, which for any straight person is an unrealistic expectation. As far as being treated like a woman outside of sexually, thats not a thing, people are individuals, your personality is dependant on your hobbies, skills, and interests, not your tits and pussy.

    • Basically you aren't experiencing anything abnormal, you are just reacting to it in a almost extremist manner thought wise, instead of admitting that thats just how things work.

    • Show All
  • Sounds like you want to wear a strap on and peg a dude. There are some weirdos who are into that.

    • No, I actually am not into pegging, haha. I just don't want to remember I am female when I am in a relationship or having sex. But that doesn't mean I have fantasies of dominating men in bed or literally fucking them. Though if I happen to fall in love with a guy who likes that, I am willing to try it for him. :)

  • We all are different and if it gives you a good orgasm why change?

  • It sounds weird as fuck.

  • Whatever works for you

    • Thanks. I try to make it work for me… somehow. :)

  • Seems like you need to be with a feminine man, I know you don’t want to transition but almost seems like you probably should or at least play the part and dress that way if you feel like that. I’ve read a lot of the comments and that’s my opinion

  • That sounds really hot actually

    • Haha, thank you. That makes me feel better.

    • It should, it is actually nice and interesting from a psychological view as well