Is a guy who has sex change surgery still a guy or does he become a woman in every way?

Is a guy who has sex change surgery still a guy or does he become a woman in every way?
If a guy has sex change surgery and hormone treatments, does he really become a woman in every sense of the word. If so, how is it that male athletes who becomes "females" are suddenly breaking world records for females in their sport when they start competing as females?

https://www.foxnews.com/sports/penn-trans-swimmer-teammate-lia-thomas-speaks
Still a guy
Vote A
Becomes a woman in every way
Vote B
Something in between
Vote C
No opinion
Vote D
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
Girl Guy
0 2

Most Helpful Guys

  • I'll laugh when people ask this question I'm not laughing at you the person that wrote it but I laugh at the question because you were born a male or a female just because you go and get a sex operation to take your penis away or try and transform I don't even know if they do it to make your pussy have a dick I don't think that's even happened but if they ever do come up with it doesn't make you more or all of a woman or all of a man if you were a woman or a man you're born a certain way that's what you're going to be no matter how you try and twist it and say I'm a woman even though I had a sex change I'm fully a woman no you're not you are a man now I'm not going to sit there and go back and forth and judge somebody because they did that they did it for a reason that's their reasoning the only person they have to talk to about that is the day they stand judgment in front of their maker who brought them into this world so that's between Jesus and that person and nobody else if they want to live on this Earth and try and act and look as a woman though they're a man that's their business I don't have anything wrong with it I'm not going to judge it now the only thing I get kind of pissy fit with or mad about is when you get all these lgbtq thing going on and they're trying to change the law and they should be able to go into any kind of bathroom or the women's bathroom when they had a sex change and all this stuff about that and trying to get into women's sports and when they were born a man that's bullshit that is complete bullshit I will totally stand up for that shit but if you want to just walk around and live your life as a woman and you were a man or vice versa knock yourself out I'm not going to judge you you could be the nicest person in the world and a great friend but it doesn't mean I have to agree with what you did

  • I noticed that the radical left keeps pushing and pushing. They keep brainwashing. It’s working and horrifying. Just 10 years ago over 80 percent of people would of voted A.

    I am a libertarian so I say do as you please with your life. I also don’t think you should be discriminated against or bullied. But I am not going to say you are a “woman” just please your feelings. You are a man who made a ínsane decision to mutilate your body.

    • We are on the very same page on this issue.

    • You have written some really good insights on other issues.

    • I appreciate your kind words!

Most Helpful Girls

  • Don't care, their choice.

    Anyone can be whatever they want, that is just fine but they cannot force others to change for them, that is what ticks me off when someone else makes a choice and then tells me I have to change for them.

    I'd probably have to go with still a man though, DNA and all.

    • The perfect statement 👌

    • "Anyone can be whatever they want," I can be an American Bald Eagle?

    • @olderandwiser Sure can, I bet you could even find a Bald Eagle outfit somewhere to wear while trying to fly and squawking like one. I didn't say you'd make a good one though.

    • Show All
  • A man doesn't become a woman by chopping his dick off and taking drugs. That's not the way it works.

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

10 27
  • If a dog bit your dick off would you become a woman? Of course not. People are more than their genitals. If a woman has naturally high testosterone do we say she's male despite being born with a vagina?

  • He's still a guy. No ovaries or uterus. He's basically a eunuch.

  • its not a woman if can't make and raise a baby, doesn't have cycles.

    and yet... they can change their sex...

    https://www.youtube.com/embed/Ak2DyDjNytI

    and it's illegal in many places to try to help people identify with their actual sex...

    go figure...

  • For me he´s something in between especially if I know his/her story. I don´t buy in the theory that there is a different between sex and gender because one can´t split character from body.
    For me it mostly depends on the person´s figure, there more it looks like a guy the higher is the chance that I treat the person as one.

  • Hmm I’m going to try get sciencey here lol. As best as I can.
    So physically no. The subject is still physically male in appearance on the rear of their body. If they really want to go full force that requires hormonal changes, other surgeries etc to mimic a female physic. Sex ie DNA can’t be changed but I don’t know if it’s a key factor in the overall gender since intersex people exist and can look fully female but have make dna simply due to an immunity to androgens. Basically it’s complicated lol.

    Emotionally that depends on the individual. Whether they truly view themselves as the opposite sex or not. There are multiple studies over the decades showcasing this due to brain chemistry issues during foetus development where the person develops as one sex mentally but physically is the other. For this I’d say yes they are a woman mentally but physically stuck in a male shell.

    Thats my two cents.

  • I wouldn't say in every sense of the word.

  • I’m think I am all for people living their lives however they want but at the same time no matter how much a guy wants to be female or a woman wants to be male.. on a chromosomal level women have two XX chromosomes and men have an XY chromosomes.


    I don’t think there is anything that can change that. But aside from that idc tbh

    • I don't care until they get in my face and tell me that "he" must now be called "she." I don't cotton to that shit.

    • I know it’s controversial. Like I said idc and if someone who was a guy wants to be called she …fine whatever but they will never know what having a period is like for example among many other things only women experience

  • Meh, women just can't get a break. They get to vote, work, own property, compete in their own sports... and all of a sudden men are "becoming" women, to take over again.

    Sure is a hard time to be a woman. Even if she "becomes" a man, she's not a very good one.

  • A surgery can't make them even 1/4th of a female. They are male and they will be a male that's unchangable

  • He's still a guy but with cosmetic surgery and/or hormone therapy

  • Genetically, they are still XY, which makes them male. However, with augmentation and hormone treatments, they no longer have a majority of testosterone, it's now estrogen. So, they still have some of the remnants of male strength.

    I've heard that some organizations are now requiring individuals to compete as their birth sex, meaning a male-to-female transition person would compete as a male.

    Though I understand why some people want to change their sex, it really confuses things in society. We have a long way to go to reconcile that.

  • Something in between. But if the person considers themself to be a girl then in day to day convo I will treat them like a girl.

  • He becomes a man with a makeshift vagina comprised of his residual penis foreskin. In other words, he becomes yucky.

  • Deep down he is still a guy and can't never bare children

  • In EVERY way? No. Biology is pretty hard to change. And sports is an issue. That doesn't make them "not a woman" though, anymore than a biological woman having high testosterone makes her "less of a woman." It does need to be addressed, but it doesn't have to be done as purposefully invalidating.

    • @snackthatsmilesback Has there ever been a case of rejecting a cis woman with elevated testosterone from competing in any female sport? According to your analysis would she have an unfair advantage which should not be allowed, why or why not?

  • His bodily features appear to be female and function as female. However, he may still might be male in some ways.

  • He’s a man.

    what determines male or female is chromosomes. He is still a man just wearing a woman’s skin. If anything he’s more of a it then female.

    sad thing is a lot of them develop mental issues, become unstable or commit suicide. Because they either can’t come to terms with it, the hormones fuck them up or they come to regret their choice but are stuck with it.

  • No. There are tremendous differences in between a male and female besides genitals. Different neurology, bone structure and mass, muscle mass and other things which cannot be changed.


    A male with no penis is simply a penisless dude no matter how much he and others in society wish differently.

  • I say he becomes a partial women while he now physically looks like a she, and his voice is high as a female now he doesn't have female genitalia or get period to be completely classified as a woman.

  • is a guy still a guy will always be a guy stay a guy

  • Show More (17)