Is it controversial to say this?

gazza_of_cyzicus Xper 5

Transwomen are men (with gender dysphoria) and transmen are women (with gender dysphoria).

0 0

Most Helpful Guys

Yaaten Xper 6
+1 y
Controversial? No, but even if it were it's still something that needs to be said. The facts are that if a person is born male that is what they shall be for the rest of their lives. The same applies to females. A person cannot change their gender any more than they can alter their birthday.
0 1 1 0
Lucretio Xper 5
+1 y
Yes, it is controversial... but i'm sure you already knew that... so it just means you made this post with an agenda in mind...

You're looking for a fight man, just stop, leave people alone.
0 0 0 1

Most Helpful Girls

psychoticanimallover Xper 6
+1 y
You don’t get to decide, David. Just like I don’t get to decide that you’re a c*nt.
1 0 0 1
BlckGrl Yoda
+1 y
It's a true statement but people will still call it transphobic
0 1 2 0

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

4 2

NopeWhatTime Xper 7
+1 y
Yes, it is controversial
0 0 0 0
Neko911 Explorer
+1 y
Yes because it's rude
1 0 0 1
- gazza_of_cyzicus
  +1 y
  But it's the truth
- Neko911
  +1 y
  I disagree
- gazza_of_cyzicus
  +1 y
  why?
- Show All Show Less
- Neko911
  +1 y
  Because I see them as the gender they identify as
- gazza_of_cyzicus
  +1 y
  So it's all about their feelings and not about biology and facts. Can a person self identify as a cat?
- Neko911
  +1 y
  Just because you have a cock doesn't make you a man. And a vagina doesn't make you a female. It only does by biology. But gender of more then that
- BlckGrl
  +1 y
  What women has a penis? What man has a vagina? You people are insane
- Neko911
  +1 y
  @BlckGrl so are idiots who can't accept someone for who they are or choose to be
- BlckGrl
  +1 y
  You still didn't answer
- Neko911
  +1 y
  @BlckGrl I don't need to because you're using dumbass transphobic people's logic and I'm not about 2 argue with you because I'll hurt your feelings if you legit try
- BlckGrl
  +1 y
  Ok sure
- Neko911
  +1 y
  @BlckGrl nope because the minute I do you'll call me racist. You didn't choose to be a black girl right? Neither do trans people choose to be trans. If it's a mental disorder then they don't choose it. So why the hell would you insult them when if someone insults you for being black you'd get mad and call them racist? Which I'm positive you would do
- BlckGrl
  +1 y
  You choose to be trans ypu choose to take hormones or testosterone. They choose to dress a certain way they choose to change their privates. I DID NOT CHOOSE TO BE BLACK
- BlckGrl
  +1 y
  Stop comparing race to an identity that is chosen and you sound very ignorant. Also yes insulting someone because of their race is racist thats literally the definition
- BlckGrl
  +1 y
  I didn't insult anyone I asked what woman has a penis and what man has a vagina and you pulled the race card
- Neko911
  +1 y
  @BlckGrl uh huh. So someone chooses to be born different with an illness as you claim? So why does dressing different or changing gender matter? Again by that logic then as a girl you can't wear pants because that's a man outfit. Or certain people can't make their hair starigjt because that's not the type of hair they have. Or curly. Your logic is stupid because then I can apply it to other things. But again you'd whine which u just did
- Neko911
  +1 y
  Nope. I used a logic. Which I knew you'd whine about even though it's the same fucking thing. You just don't wanna admit it
- BlckGrl
  +1 y
  Trans people themselves say they suffer from dysphoria, how is that offensive? Also how is me saying I didn't choose to be black stupid? Im not whining at all you compared me being black to someone play pretending dress up
- BlckGrl
  +1 y
  Transwomen are men and transmen are women you cannot change biology
- Neko911
  +1 y
  @BlckGrl because it's the same. Neither choose to be said thing. Trans people didn't decide to be trans
- Neko911
  +1 y
  Just like you can't change stupity and is why I didn't even care to argue with you
- BlckGrl
  +1 y
  You're fucking retarded dont ever compare my race to a mentally ill person ever
- BlckGrl
  +1 y
  Trans people choose to be trans they choose to take medication they choose to change their genitals they choose to dress a certain way. You want to know how I know this because my brother (sister) IS TRANS!!
- Neko911
  +1 y
  @BlckGrl says the idiot who can't accept people being born a certain way... same fucking thing dumbass
- BlckGrl
  +1 y
  Your either born xx- female or xy- male simple
- Neko911
  +1 y
  Wow... And you're still this much of a piece of shit to trans people... God I feel bad for your sibling
- Neko911
  +1 y
  Bitch bye. The fact you're this dumb and hard headed is sad. I seriously hope for your siblings sake they don't listen to any of the transphobic shit you say
- BlckGrl
  +1 y
  She agrees he always says "i know im not a man but I feel comfortable this way"
- BlckGrl
  +1 y
  Let me tell you something you old face milk mayonnaise bitch
- BlckGrl
  +1 y
  You're disgusting and quite frankly it shows on your face
- Neko911
  +1 y
  @BlckGrl wow... amazing insult
- Neko911
  +1 y
  Says the transphobic idiot
NorthwestRider Guru
+1 y
Let me guess, you are a religious nutjob?
0 0 0 1
Waldoe Guru
+1 y
no, its very accurate...
1 2 1 0
Anonymous
+1 y
Someone sounds transphobic
0 0 0 1
Anonymous
+1 y
Trans women are women and trans men are men.
1 1 1 2
- gazza_of_cyzicus
  +1 y
  Absolutely not. Soon you're going to say 2+2 is 5 because you feel like it. Facts don't care about your opinions.
- Opinion Owner
  +1 y
  Don’t care, if it makes them happy then I will respect them and I will respect how they choose to live. It’s not hurting me, it’s not stopping me from living my life. I don’t see why people gotta make a huge deal out of it. If someone chooses to identify as the opposite gender then just let them there’s literally worse things going on in the world than someone being transgender lol
- Opinion Owner
  +1 y
  And yeah it is about their feelings. If them identifying as the gender they’re born as makes them live miserably and they find living as the opposite gender makes them happy then why should we stop them? Literally all people want is to live a happy life, that’s the goal. So I’m not about to be the asshole that purposely goes out of their way to make someone feel miserable just bc I don’t agree with how they identify. I keep that shit to myself because they’re just trying to be happy and that’s all that should matter.
- Show All Show Less
- psychoticanimallover
  +1 y
  👌 👏