Sexual Relationships
+1 y

Had sex with a guy and his dick felt like he was fingering me! Share your stories?

This isn't really a question but rather than I want to hear you guys personal sex horror stories!

I feel so bad for saying this but the guy I had sex with recently was smaller than average... His dick was 3 maybe 4 inches (girth) and he was about 5 inches (length). When he was fucking me if almost felt like he was just fingering me, rather than having sex with me... I literally had to fake an orgasm. It also didn't help that I'm not physically attracted to him... so during sex, I kept my eyes closed.
0 0

Most Helpful Guys

  • Hahaha, this isn't really a horror story but it goes along with your story, kinda sorta. Way back when i was like 19 i was trying to fuck my girlfriend doggy style. But my dick didn't wanna get hard cuz i was nervous as fuck. I used to finger her a lot, so i started fingering her from behind to get hard. After maybe a minute I was ready. As soon as i stopped fingering her she looks back at me and she's looks scared and worried "you came already?" Im like "what? I didng even fuck you yet." Lmao! My dick is 8" long and almost 6" around. That was the day that I learned size doesn't matter. Either that or my fingering skills are phenominal. Not sure which actually lol.

  • A few years back the size discussion came up and this girl said she likes over 8 inches and her last boyfriend said he was 7.5, so she wouldn't want more than an inch smaller. So I grabbed a ruler and held out 8 inches (without letting her see the number) and asked her what she thought.. so said that's HUGE! Then I took it down to 7 and she said that's big too. then I showed her 6 and she said that's about how big he was. So turns out Mr. 7.5 inches wasn't all he built himself up to be. Point is, you can't always take numbers as facts when some women say specific sizes they like or don't like.

Most Helpful Girls

  • 5 inches of D can get me off. Not being sexually attracted to him is the kicker. When you're turned on, your insides swell up in excitement for him.

    Once I gashed my knee open having sex in a truck and the guy got mad that I didn't feel like continuing... and we weren't even near the crucial moment at all!

    • Sounds like a real winner!

    • He was being a real crabass! I guess we all have our moments. 😐

    • Yea we all do, but if a girl has a bloody knee or an injury that happened during sex I think you just gotta accept it and go on. Plus I wouldn't want blood all over the car! Lol :) How long were you with the guy? Was he a crabass the entire relationship?

    • Show All

  • This isn't my story. It's my friends. My guy friend liked my girl friend so he was talking smash abouy having a 9 inch dick so they go behind my house she screams for me, I run back there and she's laughing so hard she can't breath. His 9 inches turned in two inches hard... I felt so bad for him! So he lied.

    • TWO inches? rip...

  • Why did you sleep with him if you're not in love and you're not attracted to him?

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

Related Questions

Do you find visible deep cleavage of a woman attractive and sexy?
What movie describes your love life?
My boyfriend left me because I used onlyfans. I didn't cheat on him. Why did he do it?
Do you prefer cowgirl or reverse cowgirl. Why do you prefer which?

What Girls & Guys Said

4 17

  • I think I know that guy. Scott from Ashley Schaeffer BMW?😂

    https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=GoWblwKdeHg

  • What finger is 3 inches around and 5 inches long tho? Lmfaoooooo 😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • Andre the giant maybe 😂😂

    • @akadatank44 And he's dead on top of that lol

  • I had sex with a guy who was maybe 3 inches long. He only lasted about 2 minutes. Then he became angry at me.

  • Next time you need to go with a 8 inch cock. Other wise you may never be satisfied. So while choosing your next guy ask him if his cock is 8 inch or more.

  • Then why the fuck did you had set with him?

  • Yup sureeee that happened

  • Why would you have sex with someone you're not attracted to? Did he pay you?

  • Setting high standards, eh?

  • god thing im 10x6

  • So grow up and stop being a tit. You sound like an idiot. And a shallow one at that.

  • If u fuck with guy that small ofcourse u won't get any pleasure lmao.

  • so why you accept to fuck with him if you don't like him !!

  • 4 inches of girth would be the most humongous finger I've ever seen. My thumb is 2.5"

  • Get a smaller vagina, Kuntzilla :/

    • So as I said before in my many replies, I was a virgin when I fucked this dude? So my vagina isn't loose. And I like to think if I'm tight enough to a point where I can barely use tampons - my vagina is pretty normal. Guy wasn' very endowed and wasn't girthy, so it was a lose, lose scenario for me. At least he enjoyed himself 🙄😒

  • I feel bad for the guy, I'm still a virgin, 7 inches long and average girth and worried she'd think I wasn't big enough compared to her previous lovers. :(

    • Same here man. As I am also a virgin, my main worry is that I am in some way not good enough yet, probably in the duration department. I do have to ask, is it correct you are a virgin at 41? I don't mean to pry; I noticed it and wondered if that was the case.

    • @GuyWannaHelp Yep I am still a virgin.

  • Honestly I like five and cannot accept anything more than six. I dont get why many woman thinks the bigger the better. Anything more than six looks painful to me

    • Maybe you are too loose have you think about that. Five is enough to get off an average girl

    • Take it easy over there you're making too much sense ! :) Do you think girls say they like the bigger sizes bc they don't know any better, or because they are just putting on an act to appear sexually dominant?

    • There is a reason why childbirth hurts so much. But to some its easy. A 7-10 inch penis is glorified baby's head... imagine having something so big up your vagina ramming the walls. It will hurt. Such words only make stupid guys feel bigger the better and lie about. Almost every guy i talk to has at least a 7 inch dick... if everyone is really big where are the smalls?

    • Show All

  • Never measured mine but I can't be more then five or six inches (average in the west). A female friend once told me women were more complex then men and by the time your dick goes in they should be ready to go with a light breeze. I've always follow that philosophy and never had a complaint. I know women don't always orgasm on a first time with a guy (some just can't according to science) but you can tell if they are satisfied or not.

    Women notice when you take a little extra time and I swear starting with them is why I've always get a call.

  • Why did you have sex with a guy you weren't physically attracted to? -_-
    Some people I'll never understan...

  • i prefer to give head to guys with smaller dicks actually. My girlfriend does also but i make her gag I'm 8"

  • why, why are you putting yourself through this torture. if you dont' like him physically and you don't like his size. why do you continue to do it?

    • and the worst thing is that poor lad doesn't know anything about it. ... Plus she's talking behind his about about it... "so during sex, I kept my eyes closed. " I know now what to look for if I will have my first time with a girl.

    • girls can be mean as fuck, but, they won't do it to a mans face, like a real woman would, this qa's a child

  • Show More (1)

Latest Questions

Guys, when it comes to a woman's breasts, what is more important?
What taboo fantasies turn you on?
Are your fantasies about your spouse?
Why would a guy want to have anal sex with his girlfriend?
Home >  Sexual Relationships  > Had sex with a guy and his dick felt like he was fingering me! Share your stories?