Girls, which one would you pick? A handsome guy with a small-average manhood or a not so attractive guy with a big one?

There are similar questions about certain female body parts, plus men seem to worry a lot about this thing as well, so I hope people don't get offended.
Consider both the guys in discussion are similar in terms of personality compatibility.
The handsome guy not so gifted there
Vote A
The unattractive gifted guy
Vote B
Neither
Vote C
Both (secretly)
Vote D
Both (officially)
Vote E
I am a guy/See poll
Vote F
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
Girl Guy
1 5

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

21 24
  • According to many, many studies, the perfect size is... Of course the average size. It means that trough natural selection our female ancestors preferred what we call, average over what we call tiny and big. Why? Average penis size is for most women: comfortable, and practical. That doesn't translate exactly the same in virtual sex, I think. Virtual sex is 1 on 1 masturbation. Like we know, the real deal is a different story.

    Now, what's attractive? It's something subjective. What we all can agree with is how unnactractive is a poor or 0.0 self-care.

  • I do get approached often and I do have a big manhood.

    And I can tell you a big manhood can be more of a problem then a blessing.

    At big sizes like mine it takes a lot of effort to calm the women down and relax to fit it in there and even then with women with small statures, it is hard to fit the whole thing.

    Plug and play is almost impossible every time making quickies.

    If I want to make a girl cum quick it’s my fingers that do the trick. A dick means you have to take your time (unless you like the lady being in pain).

  • I prefer men with a big package, but I still wouldn’t turn down a lesser one because D is D. Mine is average, at the same time it would be nice to be a little bigger.

    • Yeah, sorry, I forgot about people that are into the same gender when I wrote the title, but it's good you got the point.

    • No problem, I like women too believe it or not.

  • I like average.

    • Well Hello there

  • I think that the size of the penis does not matter, because the woman has almost all the nerves of the vagina located between the entrance until approximately 4 centimeters inwards. therefore, a 5 cm penis is enough to satisfy a woman. My penis is 8 1/4 in length and 6 3/4 of girth when erect, but some women gave up having sex with me when they saw me naked.

  • Im not a girl so can't say

  • A handsome guy with a small one everytime.

    Big dick isn't equal to good dick. Also, I wouldn't even think of having sex with someone not attractive (at least to me).

    • everyone looks the same in the dark

    • I prefer to fuck with lights on. Also, I like morning sex so there's no escape😂

    • So if I was 28 and was there and you were attracted to me, you would wake me up by hopping up and down on me like you were breaking a bronco.

  • there's a saying that SOME women prefer a beast than the prince

  • Apparently I'm both so I don't worry to much about it really

  • Personally, I hate how you say a big dick is gifted. It’s a dick, it’s not gifted. The user may be gifted but the user doesn’t have to have a big dick.

  • gifted guy should be the choice i think :D

  • I read both as attractive

  • Have 3inch erection im 60 years old

  • I would perfer both as it's like both eyes are important

  • size don't matter if your looking for real love. but if you what to be used then go with the good looking face and the big dick because all they wanted from you is sex

  • As a younger girl, I (along with many others) am not interested in "lower regions" as I am with how the face/body looks.

  • Which has the better personality?

  • None

  • Guys don't understand than you don't need a huge dick to make a girl cum, use your damn tongue and fingers like a champ and you'll get her legs twitching all night

  • is this a guy pretending to be a girl?

    • Totally not a creep you are.

    • your grammar is terrible

    • Laughs in Yoda

  • Show More (5)