Should I leave my loving boyfriend for someone else over sex?

Hi! No judgements please-only serious answers! My boyfriend of just over a year, who I love, adores me and despite the title I really love him as well. Before we met, I was having sex with a friend (this was after a previous brutal breakup) and we had an incredible sexual connection that I've never had with any other man. Since I got together with my boyfriend, I stopped having sex with my friend but I still saw him in class and everything. But last month my boyfriend and I had a HORRIBLE argument and stupidly I went over to my friend's and we had sex (didn't plan on sleeping with him). Embarrassed as I am to say this, the sex was mind blowing. I thought about what I did and decided to put it to rest, but later that week we did it again, and we've been fucking since. I now feel absolutely awful about doing this to my boyfriend, but I'm really in a dilemma now. My boyfriend isn't bad in bed (I climax about once or twice with him) but my friend is a complete stallion (I ALWAYS lose count of the number of orgasms). 2 days ago we had our first anniversary and after my boyfriend and I had sex I called my friend, went over to his house and we had sex for hours and the next morning I couldn't help comparing him to my boyfriend and the differences are really getting to me now (physical attraction, sexual connection, penis size, passion...) and I masturbate thinking about him everyday. Awful as this sounds, now when I have sex with my boyfriend I fantasize about my friend's gorgeous enormous cock brining me to climax. I can't keep this up and am seriously considering ending it with my boyfriend. He's a great guy and I can not hurt him so I'll try to make up some reason. My friend already says he wants to be with me and loves me so why not give it a shot, I mean we connect at every level, except on religion:I'm an atheist but he's a non-practising muslim, very liberal. However I don't want to throw away a year with my boyfriend. What should I do?
Updates:
+1 y
Ok, the amount of hate I'm getting is beyond absurd. I cheated and it's wrong and I wish I'd left my boyfriend for my friend sooner at this point. But calling a woman a slut or whore gets you nowhere. I never did anything to you guys, so why are you all hating on me so much?
0 1

Most Helpful Girls

  • Sooner or later you'll get judgmental and hateful messages here because of your dilemma... however, I can somewhat relate to your situation right now, my ex appeared into in the picture when my current relationship is in the rocks. I enjoyed talking to him, flirting on the phone, sexting and even made out the 2nd and 3rd time we me again. We got a room once and to his excitement he came and we didn't get to fuck lol. However, he made sure to satisfy me by oral sex.. it was an out of this world feeling - which I don't get with my current.

    Probably, it may not be the best advise - do not base your relationship just on sex. Make a list of the pros and cons between your men. Whoever gets a high score - wins!

    • OMG thank you so much sis :) I've decided I'm going to go with my stallion and leave my boyfriend, but I will definitely try to make it a clean breakup without any unnecessary pain on his part

    • @singlebee Bro this is the face of women since forever. Getting rid of the patriarchy just meant they could reveal what an ugly face it really was.

    • @SnatchFinderGeneral OMG you actually believe women's empowerment and education make us reveal our "ugly" selves?

    • Show All
  • I will be brutally honest... but I think you know the answer. Break up with him. Do it quickly. Regrettably you are some what obsessed with your fiend (with some justification maybe) and this will destroy your relationship with your boyfriend anyway. Might as well make it a quick death rather than a slow painful one. Plus if he finds out about your friend it will probably hurt him. Be an upfront woman and call it off.

    • Thanks for your suggestion. Just the thought of throwing away a year still gets to me though. Any suggestions on how to break it off cleanly without hurting him much. I really don't want to break his heart :(

    • Hey it gonna hurt him no matter what girl. But you just have to woman up, look him in the eye and tell him its over. After time he will have more respect for you if you do it short and quick and honest (met another guy) then play some kind of stupid game. It will be easier for you as well.

    • Thanks again :) I'll try to say it face to face soon - still trembling though :(

    • Show All
  • You obviously don't care about your boyfriend. If you did you wouldn't have cheated. He deserves to be treated a lot better than that.

    Or if you want a softer version, here's a quote from Johnny Depp.

    www.quoteslike.com/.../...myquoty-W0HwKg-quote.jpg

    • Seriously to me it sounds like a guy in a women's post and posting a fake story... If not then damn I am worried all women are like this now a days... Cheating left and right :-(

    • @singlebee we don't all keep our legs in different postcodes. Some of us have morals, respect for others, and enjoy having a sex that isn't like throwing a stick into a cave.

    • I do care about him, but yeah I am breaking up with my boyfriend tomorrow.

    • Show All
  • You already know what to do. Even if you stay with the boyfriend you're going to keep cheating on him until you get caught. Follow your orgasms my friend.

    • Thanks :) Yeah I'm definitely going to talk to him tomorrow... tough talk :( I'll make up some reason. No way can I ever break it off with my friend: the fact that we come from different cultures or that he's religious pales in comparison to our sexual connection. I guess you can't choose love afterall. Anyway, I will miss my boyfriend and I wish him the best, but I'm already looking forward to starting a proper relationship with my friend :D Any suggestions on how to break up cleanly without hurting him?

    • That I don't know! It's all going to hurt no matter how much you try to soften it. I guess you could own up to your mistakes and say you realize that cutting him loose was better than living a lie? Something to that effect but worded better. I'm really terrible with break up speeches.

    • "I'll make up some reason," You're a sick fucking bitch. You boyfriend deserves to know why you don't want him and what you've been doing behind his back. You revolting slag.

    • Show All

Most Helpful Guys

  • First off yes you should leave you boyfriend. You have no concept of loyalty if all it takes is an argument to send you running to someone else regardless if the sex was intended or not you let it happen. I'm all my years of being affiliated with the aspects of relationships I still stand by the concept that sex is between to willing and ready people other than rape. Some how I even question the very notion that there is love for your boyfriend , being peel retry much all the blame for you sleeping with dude has been dumped in the BF's lap

  • How about talking to your boyfriend about coaching him, tactfully, to be more like Mr. Studly.

    www.girlsaskguys.com/.../a10152-how-to-talk-to-your-so-about-sex

    • thought about that before, and my boyfriend is already good in bed, but as harsh as this sounds, my friend is something else entirely and I'm not sure any amount of "coaching" could bring my boyfriend to that level of passion and stamina. Plus things like physical attraction and penis size and pure raw chemistry can't be coached.

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

5 31
  • Well, I hate to break it to you but sex should not make or break a relationship. But since your cheating on your boyfriend I'll say you don't really love him the way you should be so it would be best to end the relationship instead of you continuing on with your unload actions. Who's wrong in this senario, why you my dear... saying you love someone and engaging in acts that do nothing but hurt when discovered.

  • You have yourself in a position where you will never be satisfied with your current boyfriend and it is unfair to him to stay in a relationship because he deserves someone who really wants to be with him.

    When you break up with the current guy and get with your ex, some of the thrill will be gone because it is no longer cheating. The sex may be incredible but you left him previously and there must be a reason why it didn't work the first time around. You will probably encounter the same problems this time around but I suspect that you need to do this to prove to yourself whether it will work the second time.

    • Thanks for the answer. he's not my ex, he's a friend and the thrills been there when we were having sex even when I was single.

    • When I said "ex," I only meant former sexual partner. You really must break up with the current boyfriend. Under these circumstances, ironically, It is the most loving thing you can do for him.

    • I see. thanks a lot for the answer :)

  • you should tell your boyfriend you've been cheating on him then break up if you want to.

    or you should stop hooking up with this guy... but you still need to tell your boyfriend that you are cheating on him

    • Telling someone that you're cheating on them is one of the most selfish things you could ever do. The only good that could come would be minimizing the feeling of guilt you have.

    • @KingRoach Are you fucking serious. What kind of backwards planet are you on you loon.

    • @SnatchFinderGeneral name one benefit of admitting your infidelity.

    • Show All
  • Yeah...
    Is yours shy? And kind, emphatic?
    What personality does he have? How is he like? Face, eyes, height, hair, beard?
    How is his heart? His voice, his speech... And why did he choose you in his life?
    How did you affect his life? What did you change in his life? Have you made any changes in his life? P. S. Both I fell asleep and the phone is out of charge yesterday because I couldn't say good night to you..

  • I think you should break up with your boyfriend and just date your friend. Cheating on your boyfriend is a shitty thing to do... life's too short to be leading your man on. How would you feel if you found out he was cheating on you behind your back?

  • Move on. Sexual chemistry is important when you are young, so, unless your current boyfriend is a stallion in the wallet, move on.

  • Believe it or not, if you gently ask him if he'd consider letting you see this other guy on a casual basis, you might be surprised by his response. Many men secretly love the idea of their wife or girlfriend being intimate with other men, as long as it's strictly a casual relationship. When you're lying in bed with him, try bringing up the subject while you're touching his penis, and if he gets an erection hearing you talk about it, you'll know it turns him on.

  • Dump the boyfriend and go with the friend.
    You already have it in your head that you want to be with the friend anyway, so why prolong it.
    Thinking of someone else when you are in bed with your boyfriend, masturbating everyday about the friend, and even going over after having sex with your boyfriend all say you want to be with him. And, you really need to be honest and just end it.

    • Thanks for the answer! :) Will break up with him tomorrow though I know I'll miss the year we spent together :( But at least this emotional rollercoaster will be over and I'll be able to start a proper relationship with my friend.

    • Cheating loser.

    • @HonestWhiteGuy spoken like a "man" with insecurities. Shaming women for sex just shows your own short comings.

    • Show All
  • I think you are both leading yourself on, leading your boyfriend on, and you're lying to yourself. What exactly are you trying to preserve with your boyfriend? Because this is not a functional relationship, where you yell at each other and start having sex with someone else behind his back. Or do you think it is? No judgement here, I do think morality is relative, but you don't seem particularly interested or invested in your boyfriend.

  • Break up.

    You've trashed the relationship you have. I doubt this other one works out either, but you can't stay where you are.

    • Why don't you think the other one will work?

  • You really have no choice but to leave ur boyfriend.. Considering what uve put him through

    • I haven't put him through anything. He doesn't know and I don't plan on hurting him by telling him. It would break his self esteem completely if I told him the truth and I really don't want him to suffer at all.

    • See, But you HAVE... put him through a lot..(He just doesn't know it)) and i won't tell you what to do but what i will say is ignorance is definitely NOT bliss. You have to tell him one way or another.

    • Oh come on, it would break his heart if he knew. I'll just make up another reason and I absolutely cannot hurt him - I get no thrill over breaking someone's heart and he doesn't deserve it really.

    • Show All
  • It doesn't seem like you love your boyfriend.

  • Just break it up, It's all over anyway. Its up to you to decide if you want to tell your boyfriend if you've been cheating or not.

    • You called your friend a stallion and he's amazing but why was it so different from your BF? Could you not teach your boyfriend or was it just chemistry.

    • HE HAS A BIGGER DICK. THAT'S ALL.

    • @SnatchFinderGeneral Seriosuly huh doubt it would've made that much of a difference.

    • Show All
  • Bull fucking shit you didn't plan on having sex. You cheated. Your boyfriend deserves better than you.

  • I would bleach my eyes out, but I think it is too late, my eyes already got cancer from reading this.

  • You're not real.

  • Yes you should, because your boyfriend deserves better than you.

  • considered jumping off a cliff? i hear it would enhance your complexion
    sloots gon sloot

  • I would say, tell your boyfriend your cheating on him and that you love someone else and just go to your friend. There is no avoiding hurt here.

  • Sex... with your boyfriend... dinners with your boyfriend... support from your boyfriend... romantic times with your boyfriend... activities with your boyfriend... Who loves you for who you are, and who YOU love for who he is

    VS

    A wild sex night

    Do you think, it's worth it?

    • Its not just a wild night. I've known him long before my boyfriend and he's an amazing guy - we have a lot in common other than the sex.

    • Ah k, but that title though!!! Do you still LOVE your boyfriend? Think carefully.

    • I really appreciate the lack of judging and I appreciate your reply. I love my boyfriend but the truth is I've been in love with my friend for a long time but I realize now that I've been trying to hide it. My friend and I have differences, like the fact that he's and international student and a muslim (though he's barely religious) and I think those things got in the way of actually getting into a relationship with him, but I've learned to accept those.

    • Show All
  • Show More (16)