What is a woman?

[Anonymous]

Is a Trans woman a woman to you?

[SomothErgai]

So I hear this "adult human female" line a lot. I get it but let me explain why I disagree. First let me be absolutely clear that trans people are no more than just mentally ill people in need of help. And not the kind that comes at the end of a knife. Regardless of which way you slice it though (pun intended) no, "trans woman" equates to FAKE woman as far as i'm concerned.

BUT! I still disagree with the "Adult Human Female" definition and here's why.

First of all the word adult actually IS a social construct. what actually is an "adult"? Is it someone who is 18? why 18 and not 21? or 25 when our brains are supposedly "fully mature"? Why not at the age of sexual maturity? there's really no way to sensibly argue for why we should consider one thing an adult and not another. And if we're going to invoke a definition with a clear and concise meaning, the term adult just muddies the waters far too much to have a strong case. Out with it.

Secondly, Human. I know i'm going to sound just a little insane here but bare with me. What's so special about being human? Yes, yes, as far as we know humans are the only advanced species in the universe. But just, suppose for a moment that some alien race greets us one day and they have equivalent males and females of their species. that are just as, if not more, intelligent as us. It really wouldn't make a lot of sense not to call their females "women" just because they aren't human.

So we're left with "Female". I have no issue with female. but I don't think we would include female ants in the group we call women so we do still need some form of distinguishing characteristic. Well I mentioned intelligence a minute ago so why not that. How about, sentient, intelligent, female? I think this is a much more coherent and defensible definition.

And because Female is still a fundamental requirement it still does not allow for the trans insanity to infect women's spaces

[In_Trance]

A fairy tale

[Asker]

Agree 😂

[milknhoneyy]

If someone tells me they are a "she" or a "he" I simply believe them, full stop. Why would anybody bother to even question it? It doesn't affect you, & it costs nothing to simply refer to someone based on their stated identity and then move on with your life. Unless you're dating them who fucking cares? Sweet baby Jesus I'm so over all the babies crying about strangers' gender identities.

[Asker]

Keep feed into delusion your part of the problem !

[Asker]

Feeding

[Jessica405]

I say if a guy loses a leg in an accident, he is still a man

If a guy loses his dick to penile cancer, he is still a man

If a guy deliderately has his bits cut off to look like a woman, he is still a man

He may feel like a woman, look like a woman, but he is still a man

[TommyMountainFigure]

You should use that analogy to Angela Rayner. She just cannot seem to grasp it!

[Jessica405]

@TommyMountainFigure She may well be in enough trouble aldeady!

[TommyMountainFigure]

@jessica405. Indeed! But If anyone deserves it it's her, considering all the times she's used that holier than thou stance against Boris etc!

[Mac-One]

@jessica405 Would accept a man without a penis and balls or a man who has fully transitioned in female restrooms, locker rooms, and other activities? Also women who live fully as female are openly accepted in men's restrooms, locker rooms, exercise facilities, sports, etc. Why is it different for men?

[Jessica405]

@Mac-One A man should never be in female only spaces. Regardless of what he looks like, he is still a man, and should behave as such. The same applies to females who want to be malte. They are not men, never will be, and should behave as such.

[Mac-One]

@jessica405 Then why are women openly permitted in male only spaces: restrooms, locker rooms, exercise facilities, sports, and other?

[Rei13]

No but I’d still respect how that person wants to be treated and treat them as such.

[IslaTheWitch]

I don't check what people have between their legs or what hormones run in their bodies. If someone refers to themselves as a woman, I accept the fact.

[Siri137]

No, trannies obviously are not women. They don't have the right chromosomes or physical features to be called women. They weren't born female, and gender is something you just cannot change.

[IceCreamSandwich]

A woman is a woman to me, yes.

[Berethor]

Someone who was born as a male can never be a female, so it's not a woman, it's a man.

[Asker]

Agree

[electromagnetic]

Playing dress up doesn’t count.

[TommyMountainFigure]

To me, a woman is someone who doesn't have an Adam's Apple!

[JustinTheGreat]

I mean technically women have Adam’s apples, they’re just not as prominent lol Also I’m pretty sure trans women can get their Adam’s apples shaved down

[TommyMountainFigure]

@JustinTheGreat Hmmmm. if that's the case I need to amend my answer. Ok then, woman = adult version of a child showing as female on their birth certificate!

[JustinTheGreat]

Trans people can change the gender on their birth certificate

[RetroReviews]

No the whole trans thing is a mental sickness. Mirrors don't lie what you see is what you are

[EmmaMary]

NO, ABSOLUTELY NOT....AND NEVER WILL BE EITHER...PERIOD.

They are, and always will be, mentally delusional and unstable individuals.

[strateguy632]

my opinion is something like the thing we can't say.

[slatyb]

Word games about the meaning of "woman". What difference does it make? There's only one issue, and that is eligibility to play in women's sports.

[Asker]

Well we shouldn’t be having word games cause people should know what a man is and what a woman is not adding or taking away !

[Asker]

I think you are throwing that in there cause you can’t answer I think anybody can be awesome regardless of any choice they make. And I’m sorry thinking and feeling still doesn’t define you as a woman and gender and sex and your organs all play into what you are chromosomes dna so we can agree to disagree in a respectfully way thank you for your opinion.

[slatyb]

I don't care who you or anyone else deems a woman. It's not an interesting question. Why do you care if someone says they are a woman or a man or an alien from Remulak?

[Avicenna]

Of course not- it's a man pretending to be a woman.

[Dargil]

A person with XX chromosomes. Mutilation, chemicals and feelz don't matter.

[sheenagwapa]

no he is a male

[Tim2nice]

A woman is any adult human born with female genitalia

[Koneko911]

Yes she is

[Asker]

And why do you think that?

[Koneko911]

Because she is. Plain and simple. And I'm not gonna discuss with someone who feels the need to laugh when idiots here make transphobic comments. It just proves you posted this question with very cruel intentions

[Asker]

I posted it cause I’m grown and I can and I like to see others opinions but that’s not a great answer you replied back with I can laugh at whatever I want. If you don’t like scroll passed it.

[Koneko911]

And I said my comment. I don't need a reason for thinking a women is a women now do I? Why would I ever as a grown ass women question another human being on who they are? To me people who do that are laughable so

[Asker]

Well , I would question someone if they try and discredit what a woman is and isn’t born biological a woman but as far as a woman who is biological a woman I would never question her cause she knows what it is to be one and lives it everyday not thinks she is. So since your a grown woman and can’t answer makes me think differently of you. You have a great day.

[Koneko911]

Being trans doesn't discredit other women. So that logic is dumb

[Asker]

It does and also biological woman who help them push that narrative into believing they are you don’t understand how much hate woman get and for someone who cosplay and tells a woman that the only Thing makes them a woman is pushing out a baby and wanna invade what a woman is a bit laughable are you done ✅

[Koneko911]

Yeah no the fuck it don't. And the fact it bothers you so much just shows you're insecure with her femininity that a trans women bothers you. So try the fuck again on that shitty ass attempt

[Asker]

Yea it bothers ! how can I be insecure with someone who mimicking the blueprint to what a woman is and that’s Me ! Number two trans woman will never experience what a woman goes through good or bad and for you to sit up and go against an biological woman to help support their narrative is wild shows how much of a woman you are.

[Koneko911]

Yeah I'm women enough to support another fucking human being. Something you seem to be incapable of. So yes it shows how women I am that I have basic fucking himma compassion and you're a transhopic brat who feels like a trans women is a threat to her own femininity because she's the insecure in herself

[Asker]

Your woman enough to lie , ? to feed into people false narrative I’m woman enough if ask to disagree and still show compassion and love to anybody cause we all our the human race ! You can think of me of how you want to it doesn’t bother me that you call me transphobic. I think you need help but okay well have a great day

[Koneko911]

Not lying so again baby girl you are fucking reaching right now. Lmao clearly it bothers you enough you feel the need to whine about how you're right. Don't ask a question with the intention of only wanting people to be transphobic like you. Then whining like a dumbass when you get called out for it. Cause you look dumb asf

[Koneko911]

And the fact you went anon because you don't even have the fucking balls to stand by this is just sad. Clearly shows someone's ashamed or afraid to stand by what she claims

[Asker]

Are you trans? Cause you are bothered as fuck and trust me I don’t look dumb and people can have their own opinions your just the one so bothered that makes me think your are a trans woman ! Whining lol you won’t stop commenting cause problematic and stupid ! Block now

[Koneko911]

Naw baby girl I was born a women. I just dislike assholes like you

[matty1889]

yes

if you have a dick your a man if not your a women x

[Sober_Irishman]

Nope.

[JustinTheGreat]

I don’t give a fuck what someone wants to identify as. If you want to identity as a woman then I will address you as such. I don’t get why other people care so much. Someone being trans does not affect you

[TheSpaceGnome]

A woman is a female.

No to your second question.