Why would masturbating at a nude beach be offensive?

Masturbating in front of someone and staring at them is a different story. I'm talking about people minding their own business and doing their own thing in public so if that's a problem, why even normalize nudity? It doesn't hurt anyone you say? Then people jerking off and not interacting with anyone doesn't harm anyone as well. They're just trying to relieve themselves. So what's the big deal? If it's that's a big deal for nudists then they should also understand why nudity is a big deal to most people and they shouldn't push their agenda on them.

Updates:
1 y
I didn't ask this because I have intentions of doing it at any nudist colony. I wouldn't go to any of those because I'm against public nudity in the first place. I'm asking this to actually prove a point.
1 y
@Mansearching For blocking me, I'll just respond to you here. Where exactly did I say women should dress up like nuns? I see you only like to deliberately misconstrue just to give an excuse to be offended and your way to end your flawed argument. I've seen worse
0 0

Most Helpful Girls

  • Why would masturbating at a nude beach be offensive?

    Yes it would be offensive to most people and would probably get you ejected, ticketed or even arrested.

    Masturbating in front of someone and staring at them is a different story. I'm talking about people minding their own business and doing their own thing in public so if that's a problem, why even normalize nudity?

    Because nudity and lewd behavior are two different things.

    It doesn't hurt anyone you say? Then people jerking off and not interacting with anyone doesn't harm anyone as well. They're just trying to relieve themselves.

    Performing sexual acts in front of people that are not consenting to view those acts is offensive to most people.

    So what's the big deal? Because nudist and people in clothing optional locations consent to seeing others nude. They have not consented to watching someone play with themselves.

    If it's that's a big deal for nudists then they should also understand why nudity is a big deal to most people and they shouldn't push their agenda on them.

    They do understand and they don't push their agenda on anyone. They go to beaches and resorts that are specified as nudist or clothing optional. Any real nudist will not go to a textiled beach and undress, only an exhibitionist/pervert would. In nudist or clothing location people put themselves in specific locations that are seperated from the rest and designated as nudist or clothing optional.

    In short, the big difference is the consent of the other people.

    To your point, there are swingers clubs and other locations that masturbation would be accepted and the people in those locations would have consented to being in that type of environment. These places are just not the same as nudist/clothing optional locations.

    • Anyone can also say the same thing about just being nude in public as well which is a nude behavior which is why many people are still against it yet you wanna protest anyways. And there you are justifying anyone getting arrested for just doing their own thing because it's "lewd" So why even go naked in the first place? Freedom you want? As long as it doesn't hurt anyone? Then it's also freedom for people do masturbate in public as long as they're not hurting anyone. "the big difference is the consent of the other people." No one is masturbating in front of them. You know, i heard this argument from nudists a lot. "If you don't like it, don't look" so why can't they do the same thing? It just proves how hypocritical they can be.

    • If i ask why is there even a nude colony in the first place. Anyone can pretty much use the same justification as masturbating in public and say isn't pervy.

    • As I said, there are locations that welcome masturbation. Those places are for performing the acts you. The people there have consented to viewing that, its just a different place than a typical nudist location. It's respecting others boundaries. I understand you are against public nudity, and society in general is against it as well, that is why nudist and clothing optional locations are segregated from other locations. So people who find nudity offensive do not have to see other people naked.

    • Show All
  • Just don't do it

    • I have no intentions to go there anyways. My intention of asking this is to prove a point of how much they just explained masturbating being wrong in public like how "narrow minded" we are when it comes to public nudity.

Most Helpful Guys

  • The thing is that everybody's naked all the time. That's why we have to wear clothes all the time to hide it. But all you have to do to not masturbate is... nothing. You don't have to do shit. It's automatic natural part of existing to not masturbate. In fact you have to try, you have to do shit TO masturbate. So.

    Yeah it has health benefits like nudity does, yeah it feels nice like nudity, but also it feels nice in a particular way... it has health benefits in a particular way. You can't do it most of the time or those benefits change to drastic negatives, very unlike nudity. The only time nudity becomes a negative is due to weather or some external shit. Masturbating can actually be bad for you just in itself if u do it too much.

    So while nah it shouldn't be so seen as horrible nasty thing, parents shouldn't punish their kids for masturbating or any shit like that... but also, there's not much or any real benefit to allowing it in public. Almost anyone can easily get a good amount in in private. Orif not rlly private, at least out of public space.

    Whereas nudity, there often times and places you could be nude in public and see health and even some social benefits. In private we're already nude often, but can still see benefits to opening public areas for it. So there's reason to try and make it normalized. Even if not everywhere, then in some regular and pubic areas. Make sense?

    • And what else is automatic is the instinct of feeling a shame when being naked which most people have and they all have control over it which is aware clothes as we are civilized. We all evolve to wear clothes as we gain morality from building civilization. We wear clothes because we don't have fur that can hide our bodies and to protect us from the weather and sexual acts which is something we all the have. You don't do "nothing" to prevent hormones from raging because we are all naturally designed to procreate. So if you're really like to say that being naked is natural because animals are also naked, they are also the ones who are not civilized who lacks morality which is why rape and polygamy is pretty common in the animal kingdom which makes it also "natural". And by the way if you say that being naked feels nice and healthy in particular ways, i can also say something about masturbation which is a way to stimulate our natural hormones so we don't use it on other people.

    • I don't believe you even read my reply. I didn't ever use animals as justification because obviously that's a stupid fucking argument, so why would I? When I said it has health benefits and feels good, like nudity does, the "it" there was masturbating. I know it has benefits, and I agree it's perfectly natural. It shouldn't be kept from public life "because it's shameful" either—but keep reading until the end please. Shame over nudity isn't "natural" or kids would naturally be ashamed, not just after we've taught them to keep their stupid clothes on. There's whole groups of people who are developed modern day people, who also don't wear hardly any clothes (because of weather) and/or are totally cool with public nudity. I assume you don't really believe that our civilization deciding nudity was bad makes every civilization who disagrees "unciviliazed," primitive or animalistic. Cause that'd be just a really shit take. Anyway thanks for reading this far if you did! If you wanna know why I actually think nudity should be allowed publicly but not masturbating, just read the last 2 paragraphs of my first reply. That covers it.

    • It's obvious that is the thing you are trying to imply because if you like to say natural like we are living organisms trying to live normally then, what also animals do but the point is we are made different that's why what is natural for us human being is different meaning to say what is natural for us is to actually wear clothes. And you see i really love how you say it shouldn't be kept from public life because it is shameful, but that is exactly what we are also trying to say about people being used in public but you just like to diss it off anyway. It's kinda hypocritical if you think about it.

    • Show All
  • Right? And people should be able to fuck eachother and have orgies too. They're not hurting anyone. If you don't like it, don't look!

    (Sarcasm)

    • I was talking about masturbation not fucking each other. And yeah if you don't like it, don't look is what they always say so what's the big deal?

    • Because masturbation is a sexual act my guy. It's the same as sex in the eyes of the law. Whether it's acceptable to society or not is up for debate, but good luck making that argument in front of a judge

    • @Aiko_E_Lara I see your point though, and you make convincing arguments, but it's just not how it works. Maybe in the future as morals decline, but not right now

    • Show All

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

3 9
  • The whole point of a nude beach or a nudist colony is to separate being nude from being sexual. At every nude beach I'm aware of in the US, masturbation would expose you to being arrested and convicted as a sex offender, which would follow you for the rest of your life.

    Be aware that your actions have consequences, and fighting the government in court is an expensive enterprise.

    • I didn't ask this because I have intentions of doing it at any nudist colony. I wouldn't go to any of those because I'm against public nudity in the first place. I'm asking this to actually prove a point. If the point if being nude is because freedom of doing so is what they want, then freedom is what they get and people should also be free to just masturbate and do their thing without harassing anyone. And if they like to make it a big deal and say anyone who masturbate deserves to be arrested, then it's not different if someone protests about public nudity being illegal. They like to talk about how it inappropriate is but they don't see themselves being naked in front of anyone as inappropriate. It just shows how hypocritical that agenda can be.

    • Also i'd like to point out how they cherry pick on what's natural which are the only thing that benefits them while ignoring the consequences and the downside about nudity. It's just like saying "it's ok to not brush your teeth but it's not ok if your breath stinks"

    • You are really off in space. First, the term "nudist colony" went out long ago because nude resorts and nude beaches, etc., are not colonies of any kind! Nudity in a nude resort is not in a public place, it is private property. And nude beaches are accepted as places that one can go nude because they are known as nude beaches and people who want to avoid them can do so and not be "offended". If the nude people wander off the nude beach onto a non-nude beach they can be arrested.

    • Show All
  • A nudist beach isn't anything to do with sex, it's just people who enjoy/prefer being naked. I can't tell if you're trolling/being sarcastic but I'm surprised if you honestly can't understand why someone masturbating in public in front of people is inappropriate

    • And masturbating isn't sex. There's a reason why people who never had sex partners are called virgins despite masturbating a lot. I'm actually being serious in this question. If you all want freedom "as long as it doesn't hurt anyone" then freedom it is. Masturbate "as long as it doesn't hurt anyone". And if you nudists make that a big deal, then you're a hypocrite. Can you read the description again? "Masturbating in front of someone and staring at them is a different story. I'm talking about people minding their own business and doing their own thing in public so if that's a problem, why even normalize nudity?"

    • Same arguments you nudists like to bring up. If you don't like it, don't look. And you say it's that simple?

    • Ofcourse you can't tell if im trolling or not. Because no one else has balls to ask this kind of question. I do. And I have every solid arguments prepared.

  • for me, there’s a big difference between sex and nudity. Being a naturist is all about not wearing clothes, it’s non sexual. Having sex in public at a beach or anywhere is something very different….. many would find offensive because it’s a sex act. Being nude is not a sex act. It’s hanging out in nature unclothed, how we were made

    • And did I talk about having sex? I'm talking about just masturbating and minding their own business. There's a reason why people who never had sex partners are called virgins despite masturbating a lot. It's no secret that most people would actually masturbate in private fantasizing who knows who and if you know, how is it any different to just actually doing it in public anyways if you 're already aware?

    • Ok true, u didn’t say sex, but masturbating is just as bad. It’s a sexual act. I don’t think people should masturbate anywhere in public

    • Then what would be your logic behind that when you're justifying the normalization of nudity?

    • Show All
  • Yes it would be. Its likely illegal as well depending on where you did it. Most laws that allow for nudity still forbid sexual activity.

    • And why would masturbating in public be inappropriate and bothersome when you all like to argue "If you don't like it, don't look" when someone is naked in public? Why isn't that even an easy thing for you to do? If being naked in front of anyone doesn't hurt you say, then so is masturbating but why make it a big deal?

  • Depends on the etiquette of the nude beach. Some beaches are open to sexual activity, most are not.

    Most nude beaches are intended to behave as a normal beach, with the exception of course that everyone's wearing different variations of the same 'suit.' You can't masturbate at a regular beach, so that applies. Some of those beaches are also treated as family beaches. The nude beach I go to is such a one where people do bring their kids. Not likely anyone there would take kindly to the sight of someone relieving themselves there.

    I did visit one where sex is allowed (using allowed loosely ad I've never seen anything against it) in France a few years ago. For the most part people were minding their own business while around others having sex.

    • Then that's cherry picked. It's like you only get to decide on what's "normal". "Normal person" and "Naked in front of anyone" just doesn't go well together just to be real. And why would masturbating in public be inappropriate and bothersome when you all like to argue "If you don't like it, don't look" when someone is naked in public? Why isn't that even an easy thing for you to do?

    • How am i the one deciding what's normal? I merely stated that most nude beaches follow the same rules as any other beach minus the dress code. What's normal is subjective. I've been around nudist culture since I was 16 so it's my norm. As such I can tell you from experience that what you're describing isn't part of the norm.

    • Well that proves it. That's hypocrisy. I have no intentions to go there anyways. My intention of asking this is to prove a point of how much they just explained masturbating being wrong in public like how "narrow minded" we are when it comes to public nudity.

    • Show All
  • Go try it.

    • Nice reverse psychology. I should also tell nudists to go naked in public in the middle east.

    • It's not reverse psychology. It's mental judo, and I won. I just got you to argue against yourself. Easy Peasy.

    • If you think what you said actually worked on me, perhaps you read the update of the description? Here's what I said. "I didn't ask this because I have intentions of doing it at any nudist colony. I wouldn't go to any of those because I'm against public nudity in the first place. I'm asking this to actually prove a point." Because there's just no way of telling if you're just a moron like those nudists who go out of their way get naked in public and make parades about it or you're just ignorant about the point of this question. That's not mental judo. That's just ignorance.

    • Show All
  • Don't masturbate in public anywhere is the rule

    • Then being naked in public should also be a rule

    • If you can't control yourself when you see someone naken then you should maybe not be in public

    • Then if you can't control yourself not being naked in public then maybe you should leave society. It's like you only get to decide on what's natural or not.

    • Show All
  • One for the duh file

    • For the update: Why would you be against public nudity? You were born naked. Ev1 in that room saw you naked.

    • I was born naked but I wasn't born in public. And no one knows how I'd look naked now and not even the doctors do. I make exceptions for emergency situations but going to the beach is not an emergency. Also for the same reason why you'd be against masturbating in public. And if you're gonna make that a big deal, then guess what? So does anti nudists having a point of view of your agenda.

    • I don't have an agenda. If you don't wanna be naked at a nude beach, then don't go to said beach. If you do go to said beach, no one there will force you to be nude. Its always optional. My (past) girlfriend and I went to one. She went nude bc she didn't want tan lines on butt or boobs. I went w ith my trunks on. We went for a walk, talked to almost every person, no one said a damn thing about anything. Again if your that against nudity, don't go to said beach. Or you can hide in the corner inside your home and never leave. Just leave people who want to be nude alone and keep personal subjective feelings to yourself.

    • Show All
  • Not everyone wants to see you jerk the meat

    • Well not everyone likes to see anyone naked or to know the fact that you're naked in front of strangers. If you like to make that a big deal, it's quite hypocritical if you dis off anyone making nudity a big deal.

  • thats drawing attention to yourself

    • A common argument nudists like to bring up is "if you don't like it, don't look" and they don't consider themselves drawing attention for being naked in public for whatever hypocritical reason

  • There are beaches where that is what goes on. A true nudist beach isn't like that

    • lol you all have your own idea of what's a "true" nude beach just like how you all just have your own idea of what's natural or not. You only cherry pick on those things you like and call them natural if you think it benefits you.

  • Really no point to asking if you've already decided you know the answer and have an argument for every answer you disagree with. Since you're so sure, just go do it and we'll all pretend to be shocked when it didn't go how you thought.

    • And it would exactly prove my point about how you nudists just like to cherry pick on what's natural without taking a look at the other story. In other words, hypocrisy. It's ironic when you say i have no point asking when you've actually proven my point.