How do you feel about evolutionary psychologists saying that men are naturally inclined to commit violence and rape?

There's a stereotype about feminists viewing men as naturally inclined to commit violence and rape. There are indeed some radical feminists who feel that way, but I've seen that idea espoused much more by evolutionary psychologists. I haven't noticed as much outcry against it, though. Some examples:

"You Should Know How The Male Brain Reacts To Handling A Gun: The evolutionary psychology of mass shootings." Frank T. McAndrew, Professor of Psychology, Knox College
https://www.huffpost.com/entry/young-males-guns-psychology_n_566226e4e4b08e945fefae4c

"A Natural History of Rape: Biological Bases of Sexual Coercion is a 2000 book by the biologist Randy Thornhill and the anthropologist Craig T. Palmer, in which the authors argue that evolutionary psychology can account for rape among human beings, maintain that rape is either a behavioral adaptation or a byproduct of adaptive traits such as sexual desire and aggressiveness, and make proposals for preventing rape." https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Natural_History_of_Rape

"Although they argue that rape is biological, Thornhill and Palmer do not view it as inevitable. Their recommendations for rape prevention include teaching young males not to rape, punishing rape more severely, and studying the effectiveness of "chemical castration." They also recommend that young women consider the biological causes of rape when making decisions about dress, appearance, and social activities."
https://www.abc.net.au/science/articles/2000/01/17/93527.htm
How do you feel about evolutionary psychologists saying that men are naturally inclined to commit violence and rape?
So do you find these claims by evolutionary psychologists to be offensive?
I agree, so I'm not offended by either radical feminists or evolutionary psychologists saying this
Vote A
I disagree, but I'm still not offended by either radical feminists or evolutionary psychologists saying this
Vote B
I'm only offended by radical feminists saying this (please explain why)
Vote C
I'm offended by both equally
Vote D
I'm offended by both, but moreso by radical feminists who say it (please explain why)
Vote E
I'm offended by both, but moreso by evolutionary psychologists who say it (please explain why)
Vote F
Select gender and age to cast your vote:
Girl Guy
Updates:
+1 y
It's important to note that evolutionary psychology is very different from regular psychology. Most regular psychologists hate evolutionary psychology. Basically what evolutionary psychologists do is look at modern occurrences and assume there MUST be an evolutionary basis for all of them, despite the wide differences in behavior/norms across different societies.
+1 y
The most alarming part of these results is the percentage of people who actually agree with the hypothesis
1 5

Scroll Down to Read Other Opinions

What's Your Opinion? Sign Up Now!

What Girls & Guys Said

16 110
  • I don't think an entire gender is naturally inclined to violence of the other.
    That would literally go against evolution. Evolution works to help a species survive better, this would counterproductive.

    Besides, rapists are almost always formed due to lack of proper upbringing.

  • EP is a farce at best.
    Funny how the "evolutionists" try to work backward to develop a premise, and then wrap an ideology around to "explain" what has already happened and "why".
    Coming from the HuffPo and ABC website cites, I wouldn't expect much (if any?) meaningful truth anyway.
    Are the males the more aggressive of the sexes in most animals? Yes. The thing that sets mankind apart from the lower animals is that God gave us a conscience. Some people just haven't learned how to use their, and EPs and others are simply attempting to frame a "plausible" explanation to "normalize" the activities. It's been going on for a long time and it will continue if not checked.

  • It's simpler than that: some men could consider rape if other ways of getting sex fail them.

    Same as eating shit. If you have good food you will favor that, but if you are in hunger you would eat whatever.

    The thing is there's no scarcity of ugly women willing to fuck, in the worst case.

    • Just because someone needs sex or is horny doesn't mean to do whatever it takes, and definitely doesn't make rape an acceptable answer! There are other ways to relieve than sex

    • Plenty of people die of starvation instead of eating their own shit

    • * so that's a load of bs what u said

    • Show All
  • Bullshit.
    It's cultural.
    If it's allowed or not opposed sufficiently then it will occur more often.

  • I agree with the base science but I think its lazy thinking to extend it to modern men.

  • did you seriously just cited "huffington post" to claim anything about "science". get fucking real. i know i sound aggressive and mean but if you think that huffinton post has anything to do with actual science, then you are litterally insane.

    read actual science, not tabloids! the science is very clear on this one. men are not inherently psychologically conditioned to commit sexual acts of violence. a human can generally be conditioned to be that way. it can not be evolutionary, cause evolution would automatically sort out shit that is detrimental to reproduction and rape implies a male that doesn't care for the offspring, hence it's a detriment for reproduction that will never be prevalent evolutionary speaking which is "not" to say that this won't ever happen.

    • I agree with your statements about the evolutionary ineffectiveness of rape. My question was whether you're offended by evolutionary psychologists, like the ones I linked, who make these claims.

    • rape happens in nature. that doesn't mean there's a natural predisposition for rape. it's an irregularity in the human species. in other species, where a baby will survive without any further care, rape is the normal mode of procreation. not for humans.

    • That still doesn't answer my question though. My question is: are you offended by evolutionary psychologists who say stuff like this?

    • Show All
  • So... You're basically trying to say all men are born rapists by linking articles.

    Ugh... Men use to be hairier and dumber too.

    Oh geez so when women say all men are stupid that must be true too..

    • That's not what I'm saying. I disagree with the articles. I'm linking the articles and asking if you're offended because I haven't seen much backlash against it. "so when women say all men are stupid that must be true too.." these evolutionary psychologists are men

    • Well just use common sense. It's not that hard to figure out that men aren't born rapists.

  • Misandry.
    Alright. That's enough of GAG for me for today. See ya tomorrow.

  • I view evolutionary psychologists the same way I view psychologists who insist that gaslighting is a thing.

    They're dumbasses.

  • Shhh!!! Don't tell that to men, or they would use it to there advantage and do rapes.

    Lol if that was really true no women in the world would be safe and rapes would be very common and daily news and it wouldn't be looked as rape itself and something that's natural because evolutionary psychology says so

    • It’s like saying anyone who owns a firearm is a murderer.

  • I disagree I don’t think most men are that way or there wouldn’t be a woman in the world who hadn’t been raped

  • You always come up with the most wildest and craziest questions

  • Rape is an intrinsic element of patriarchy. It has to do with power and control, rather than a sexual gratification.

    A rapist find excitement in controlling and having the power to continue doing so. Such behavior is an antisocial characteristic that doesn't develop in matriarcal societies, where sexual violence is condemned. So, I think that we men, are predisposed to commit rape under a patriarcal society, when that patriarchy is teached and encited within the family.

    When the family is a barrier for the patriarcal views, there will less likely be an rapist. From a social psychology perspective, rape rates depend on the social construct we live in. For evolutionary phychologist, it can means that our worst biological nature, can be dormat or increasing, depending on the context of our genetics, in relation to our enviorment.

  • What's interesting to also note is how so many women are massively turned on at being held down, choked, rough sex that simulates rape.

  • That's far more powerful an impulse to protect and provide.

    To build and to love.

  • I'm not offended and think they are wrong.
    Under normal conditions women favor winners and competition to be the winner is strong instinct in men. You don't need to rape when you're the winner because you can obtain sex without social consequences.
    Of course taking women as loot or group rapes of conquered women are common in war times, but this isn't normal condition of a society.

    • Plenty of rich and famous people commit rape even though they would be able to get sex consensually.

  • So men cause something like 90% of crime so clearly they are more prone to violence. You cannot have an “opinion” on this, it is fsct. Much like folks of African ancestry cause more rapes and murders than their proportion of the population alone would suggest. Are they more prone to violence? The answer is obvious to those who haven’t been brainwashed

  • I think it just more comes down to a lot of people are just really shitty. And some are just fucking evil. Men and women both. More guys than girls. But its how it will always be. Its human nature.
    But really good men also exist that would rather die than see a woman get hurt.

  • I think it's probably true. But I am very glad that most of us are civilized.

    I agree with Thornhill and Palmer.

    As far as being offended, I'm not offended by any of the theories you mentioned. Everyone is entitled to their own point of view.

  • Yeah more like than women, and lion are more likely to kill you without remorse, this isn’t news

    • So are you also okay with radical feminists saying that?

    • It’s not radical to say the stronger gender is more like to take advantage of the weak gender. The problem is if you think all men can’t stop themselves raping women. Plus if women where stronger than us physically don’t you think they would take advantage of that too, the world is an unfair place so just deal with it and stop acting like it should be fair.

  • Show More (66)